The “law of bone transformation”:​ a case of crying Wolff?

Bertram, John E. A.; Swartz, Sharon M.

Affiliations

¹Department of Biology, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada

²Department of Cell, Molecular, and Structural Biology, Northwestern University, Chicago, Illinois, U.S.A.

Links

DOI: 10.1111/j.1469-185X.1991.tb01142.x

PubMed: 1932466

WoS: A1991GE86700001

History

Received: 1990-05-31

Revised: 1991-01-12

Accepted: 1991-02-21

Cited Works (47)

Year	Entry
1979	Lanyon LE, Bourn S. The influence of mechanical function on the development and remodeling of the tibia: an experimental study in sheep. J Bone Joint Surg. March 1979;61A(2):263-273.
1988	Whalen RT, Carter DR, Steele CR. Influence of physical activity on the regulation of bone density. J Biomech. 1988;21(10):825-837.
1986	Biewener AA, Swartz SM, Bertram JEA. Bone modeling during growth: dynamic strain equilibrium in the chick tibiotarsus. Calcif Tiss Int. November 1986;39(6):390-395.
1978	Uhthoff HK, Jaworski ZF. Bone loss in response to long-term immobilisation. J Bone Joint Surg. August 1978;60B(3):420-429.
1974	Lanyon LE. Experimental support for the trajectorial theory of bone structure. J Bone Joint Surg. 1974;56B(1):160-166.
1971	Heřt J, Lišková M, Landa J. Reaction of bone to mechanical stimuli, I: continuous and intermittent loading of tibia in rabbit. Folia Morphol (Praha). August 1971;19(3):290-300.
1972	Chamay A, Tschantz P. Mechanical influences in bone remodeling: experimental research on Wolff's law. J Biomech. March 1972;5(2):173-180.
1979	Goodship AE, Lanyon LE, McFie H. Functional adaptation of bone to increased stress: an experimental study. J Bone Joint Surg. June 1979;61A(4):539-546.
1981	Churches AE, Howlett CR. The response of mature cortical bone to controlled time-varying loading. In: Cowin SC, ed. Mechanical Properties of Bone. The Joint ASME-ASCE Applied Mechnics, Fluids Engineering and Bioengineering Conference; June 22-24, 1981; Boulder, CO. New York, NY: American Society of Mechical Engineers; 1981:69-80.
1984	Meade JB, Cowin SC, Klawitter JJ, Van Buskirk WC, Skinner HB. Bone remodeling due to continuously applied loads. Calcif Tiss Int. March 1984;36(suppl 1):S25-S30.
1981	Carter DR, Harris WH, Vasu R, Caler WE. The mechanical and biological response of cortical bone to in vivo strain histories. In: Cowin SC, ed. Mechanical Properties of Bone. The Joint ASME-ASCE Applied Mechnics, Fluids Engineering and Bioengineering Conference; June 22-24, 1981; Boulder, CO. New York, NY: American Society of Mechical Engineers; 1981:81-92.
1989	Burr DB, Schaffler MB, Yang KH, Lukoschek M, Sivaneri N, Blaha JD, Radin EL. Skeletal change in response to altered strain environments: is woven bone a response to elevated strain? Bone. 1989;10(3):223-233.
1984	Lanyon LE. Functional strain as a determinant for bone remodeling. Calcif Tiss Int. March 1984;36(suppl 1):S56-S61.
1985	Burr DB, Martin RB, Schaffler MB, Radin EL. Bone remodeling in response to in vivo fatigue microdamage. J Biomech. 1985;18(3):189-200.
1981	Woo SL-Y, Kuei SC, Amiel D, Gomez MA, Hayes WC, White FC, Akeson WH. The effect of prolonged physical training on the properties of long bone: a study of Wolff's Law. J Bone Joint Surg. June 1981;63A(5):780-787.
1984	Currey JD. Mechanical Adaptations of Bone. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press; 1984.
1981	Doty SB. Morphological evidence of gap junctions between bone cells. Calcif Tiss Int. 1981;33(5):509-512.
1982	Frost HM. Review article mechanical determinants of bone modeling. Metab Bone Dis Rel Res. 1982;4(4):217-229.
1985	Frost HM. The pathomechanics of osteoporoses. Clin Orthop Relat Res. November 1985;200:198-225.
1981	Roesler H. Some historical remarks on the theory of cancellous bone structure (Wolff's Law). In: Cowin SC, ed. Mechanical Properties of Bone. The Joint ASME-ASCE Applied Mechnics, Fluids Engineering and Bioengineering Conference; June 22-24, 1981; Boulder, CO. New York, NY: American Society of Mechical Engineers; 1981:27-42.
1983	Parfitt AM, Mathews CH, Villanueva AR, Kleerekoper M, Frame B, Rao DS. Relationships between surface, volume, and thickness of iliac trabecular bone in aging and in osteoporosis: implications for the microanatomic and cellular mechanisms of bone loss. J Clin Invest. October 1983;72(4):1396-1409.
1980	Lanyon LE. The influence of function on the development of bone curvature: an experimental study on the rat tibia. J Zool. 1980;192(4):457-466.
1982	Lanyon LE, Goodship AE, Pye CJ, MacFie JH. Mechanically adaptive bone remodelling. J Biomech. 1982;15(3):141-154.
1892	Wolff J. Das Gesetz der Transformation der Knochen. Berlin: Hirschwald; 1892.
1984	Lanyon LE, Rubin CT. Static vs dynamic loads as an influence on bone remodelling. J Biomech. 1984;17(12):897-905.
1968	Currey JD. The effect of protection on the impact strength of rabbits’ bones. Acta Anat. 1968;71(1):87-93.
1988	Parfitt AM. Bone histomorphometry: proposed system for standardization of nomenclature, symbols, and units. Calcif Tiss Int. May 1988;42(5):284-286.
1986	Jaworski ZFG, Uhthoff HK. Reversibility of nontraumatic disuse osteoporosis during its active phase. Bone. January 1986;7(6):431.
1982	Rubin CT, Lanyon LE. Limb mechanics as a function of speed and gait: a study of functional strains in the radius and tibia of horse and dog. J Exp Biol. December 1982;101:187-211.
1985	Rubin CT, Lanyon LE. Regulation of bone mass by mechanical strain magnitude. Calcif Tiss Int. 1985;37(4):411-417.
1970	Donaldson CL, Hulley SB, Vogel JM, Hattner RS, Bayers JH, McMillan DE. Effect of prolonged bed rest on bone mineral. Metabolism. December 1970;19(12):1071-1084.
1980	Jaworski ZFG, Liskova-Kiar M, Uhthoff HK. Effect of long-term immobilisation on the pattern of bone loss in older dogs. J Bone Joint Surg. February 1980;62B(1):104-110.
1981	Carter DR, Caler WE, Spengler DM, Frankel VH. Fatigue behavior of adult cortical bone: the influence of mean strain and strain range. Acta Orthop Scand. 1981;52(5):481-490.
1983	Biewener AA, Thomason J, Lanyon LE. Mechanics of locomotion and jumping in the forelimb of the horse (Equus): in vivo stress developed in the radius and metacarpus. J Zool. 1983;201(1):67-82.
1984	Carter DR. Mechanical loading histories and cortical bone remodeling. Calcif Tiss Int. March 1984;36(suppl 1):S19-S24.
1988	Skerry TM, Bitensky L, Chayen J, Lanyon LE. Loading-related reorientation of bone proteoglycan in vivo: strain memory in bone tissue? J Orthop Res. July 1988;6(4):547-551.
1978	Morey ER, Baylink DJ. Inhibition of bone formation during space flight. Science. September 22, 1978;201(4361):1138-1141.
1989	Weinreb M, Rodan GA, Thompson DD. Osteopenia in the immobilized rat hind limb is associated with increased bone resorption and decreased bone formation. Bone. 1989;10(3):187-194.
1984	Rubin CT. Skeletal strain and the functional significance of bone architecture. Calcif Tiss Int. March 1984;36(suppl 1):S11-S18.
1987	Carter DR. Mechanical loading history and skeletal biology. J Biomech. 1987;20(11-12):1095-1109.
1977	Jones HH, Priest JD, Hayes WC, Tichenor CC, Nagel DA. Humeral hypertrophy in response to exercise. J Bone Joint Surg. March 1977;59A(2):204-208.
1983	Jee WS, Wronski TJ, Morey ER, Kimmel DB. Effects of spaceflight on trabecular bone in rats. Am J Physiol Regul Integr Comp Physiol. 1983;244(3):R310-R314.
1984	Cowin SC. Mechanical modeling of the stress adaptation process in bone. Calcif Tiss Int. March 1984;36(suppl 1):S98-S103.
1979	Starkebaum W, Pollack SR, Korostoff E. Midroelectrode studies of stress-generated potentials in four-point bending of bone. J Mater Res. September 1979;13(5):729-751.
1984	Rubin CT, Lanyon LE. Dynamic strain similarity in vertebrates: an alternative to allometric limb bone scaling. J Theo Biol. March 21, 1984;107(2):321-327.
1988	Meunier PJ. Assessment of bone turnover by histomorphometry in osteoporosis. In: Riggs BL, Melton LJ III, eds. Osteoporosis: Etiology, Diagnosis, and Management. New York, NY: Raven Press; 1988:317-332.
1984	Rubin CT, Lanyon LE. Regulation of bone formation by applied dynamic loads. J Bone Joint Surg. March 1984;66A(3):397-402.

Cited By (53)

Year	Entry
1992	Hall BK. Historical overview of studies on bone growth and repair. In: Hall BK, ed. Bone. Volume 6: Bone Growth — A. Boca Raton, FL: Inc., CRC Press; 1992:1-19.
2001	Cowin SC. The false premise of Wolff's Law. In: Cowin SC, ed. Bone Mechanics Handbook. 2nd ed. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press; 2001:30-1–30-15.
2025	Skedros JG. Biomechanical foundations of histological analysis in limb bones: the crucial role of load-complexity categorization and collagen fiber orientation analysis when interpreting bone adaptation. In: Stout SD, Crowder C, eds. Bone Histology: A Biological Anthropological Perspective. 2nd ed. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press; 2025:150-224.
2002	Currey JD. Bones: Structure and Mechanics. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press; 2002.
1998	Martin RB, Burr DB, Sharkey NA. Skeletal Tissue Mechanics. New York, NY: Springer-Verlag; 1998.
2006	Ruff C, Holt B, Trinkaus E. Who's afraid of the big bad Wolff? “Wolff's law” and bone functional adaptation. Am J Phys Anthropol. April 2006;129(4):484-498.
2020	Mulder B, Stock JT, Saers JPP, Inskip SA, Cessford C, Robb JE. Intrapopulation variation in lower limb trabecular architecture. Am J Phys Anthropol. September 2020;173(1):112-129.
1996	Yaszemski MJ, Payne RG, Hayes WC, Langer R, Mikos AG. Evolution of bone transplantation: molecular, cellular and tissue strategies to engineer human bone. Biomaterials. January 1996;17(2):175-185.
1994	Forwood MR, Turner CH. The response of rat tibiae to incremental bouts of mechanical loading: a quantum concept for bone formation. Bone. November–December 1994;15(6):603.
1995	Forwood MR, Turner CH. Skeletal adaptations to mechanical usage: results from tibial loading studies in rats. Bone. October 1995;17(4)(suppl):197S-205S.
2011	Barak MM, Lieberman DE, Hublin J-J. A Wolff in sheep's clothing: trabecular bone adaptation in response to changes in joint loading orientation. Bone. December 2011;49(6):1141-1151.
1993	Forwood MR, Burr DB. Physical activity and bone mass: exercises in futility? Bone Miner. May 1993;21(2):89-112.
2019	Liu P, Liang X, Li Z, Zhu X, Zhang Z, Cai L. Decoupled effects of bone mass, microarchitecture and tissue property on the mechanical deterioration of osteoporotic bones. Compos Pt B-Eng. November 15, 2019;177:107436.
1994	Turner CH, Forwood MR, Otter MW. Mechanotransduction in bone: do bone cells act as sensors of fluid flow? FASEB J. August 1994;8(11):875-878.
1995	Klein-Nulend J, van der Plas A, Semeins CM, Ajubi NE, Frangos JA, Nijweide PJ, Burger EH. Sensitivity of osteocytes to biomechanical stress in vitro. FASEB J. March 1995;9(5):441-445.
1997	Turner CH, Annet V, Pidaparti RMV. A uniform strain criterion for trabecular bone adaptation: do continuum-level strain gradients drive adaptation? J Biomech. June 1997;30(6):555-563.
2005	Ruimerman R, Hilbers P, van Rietbergen B, Huiskes R. A theoretical framework for strain-related trabecular bone maintenance and adaptation. J Biomech. April 2005;38(4):931-941.
2019	Yang H, Xu X, Bullock W, Main RP. Adaptive changes in micromechanical environments of cancellous and cortical bone in response to in vivo loading and disuse. J Biomech. May 24, 2019;89:85-94.
1997	Guldberg RE, Caldwell NJ, Guo XE, Goulet RW, Hollister SJ, Goldstein SA. Mechanical stimulation of tissue repair in the hydraulic bone chamber. J Bone Miner Res. August 1997;12(8):1295-1302.
2003	Lieberman DE, Pearson OM, Polk JD, Demes B, Crompton AW. Optimization of bone growth and remodeling in response to loading in tapered mammalian limbs. J Exp Biol. September 15, 2003;206(18):3125-3138.
2006	Pontzer H, Lieberman DE, Momin E, Devlin MJ, Polk JD, Hallgrímsson B, Cooper DML. Trabecular bone in the bird knee responds with high sensitivity to changes in load orientation. J Exp Biol. January 2006;209(1):57-65.
2007	Skedros JG, Baucomb SL. Mathematical analysis of trabecular “trajectories” in apparent trajectorial structures: the unfortunate historical emphasis on the human proximal femur. J Theo Biol. January 7, 2007;244(1):15-45.
2014	Christen P, Ito K, Ellouz R, Boutroy S, Sornay-Rendu E, Chapurlat RD, van Rietbergen B. Bone remodelling in humans is load-driven but not lazy. Nat Commun. September 2014;5:4855.
1994	Parfitt AM. The two faces of growth: benefits and risks to bone integrity. Osteoporos Int. November 1994;4(6):382-398.
2007	Fratzl P, Weinkamer R. Nature’s hierarchical materials. Prog Mater Sci. November 2007;52(8):1263-1334.
2004	Pearson OM, Lieberman DE. The aging of Wolff's “law”: ontogeny and responses to mechanical loading in cortical bone. Yearb Phys Anthropol. 2004;47:63-99.
1998	Bateman TA. Cytokine Therapies for Short-Term Disuse Osteopenia Models in Murines [PhD thesis]. University of Colorado; 1998.
1993	Lieberman DE. Mobility and Strain: The Biology of Cementogenesis and Its Application to the Evolution of Hunter-Gatherer Seasonal Mobility During the Late Quaternary in the Southern Levant [PhD thesis]. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University; January 1993.
2006	Main RP. Skeletal Mechanics, Bone Histomorphology, and Growth in Tetrapods [PhD thesis]. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University; September 2006.
2007	Devlin MJ. Interactions of Estrogen, Strain, and Bone Growth: Implications for Human Skeletal Robusticity [PhD thesis]. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University; September 2007.
2005	Zumwalt AC. The Effect of Endurance Exercise on the Morphology of Muscle Attachment Sites: An Experimental Study in Sheep (Ovis Aries) [PhD thesis]. Johns Hopkins University; March 2005.
2007	Organ JM. The Functional Anatomy of Prehensile and Nonprehensile Tails of the Platyrrhini (primates) and Procyonidae (carnivora) [PhD thesis]. Johns Hopkins University; September 2007.
2020	Bennison MBL. The Role of Cancellous Bone Architecture in Misalignment and Side Effect Errors [Master's thesis]. Sudbury, ON: Laurentian University; 2020.
2019	Du J. Mechanical Adaptation of Human Trabecular Bone: Experimental and Computational Study [PhD thesis]. Loughborough University; 2019.
1995	Yaszemski MJ. The Design, Synthesis, Characterization, and Mechanical Testing of a Novel Degradable Polymeric Biomaterial for Use as a Bone Substitute [PhD thesis]. Cambridge, MA: Massachusetts Institute of Technology; June 1995.
1992	Bloomfield SA. Site-Specific Changes in Bone Mass and Alterations in Calciotropic Hormones With Electrical Stimulation Exercise in Individuals With Chronic Spinal Cord Injury [PhD thesis]. The Ohio State University; 1992.
2001	Tanck EJM. Mechanical Regulation of Bone Development [PhD thesis]. Nijmegen, Netherlands: Katholieke Universiteit Nijmegen; June 2001.
2001	Kim DG. Micromechanical Analysis of Bone At a Bone-Implant Interface [PhD thesis]. Troy, NY: Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute; April 2001.
2005	Ruimerman R. Modeling and Remodeling in Bone Tissue [PhD thesis]. Eindhoven University of Technology; 2005.
2006	Macdonald HM. Effectiveness of a School-Based Physical Activity Intervention for Increasing Bone Strength in Children: Action Schools! British Columbia [PhD thesis]. Vancouver, BC: University of British Columbia; July 2006.
1999	Judex S. The Effect of Exercise-Induced Mechanical Stimuli on Cortical Bone [PhD thesis]. Calgary, AB: University of Calgary; 1999.
2021	Besler BAA. Bone as an Orientable, Smooth Surface: Distance Transforms, Morphometry, and Adaptation [PhD thesis]. Calgary, AB: University of Calgary; August 2021.
2021	Kemp TD. An Inverse Interface Evolution Problem to Identify Participant-Specific Bone Microarchitecture Adaptation [Master's thesis]. Calgary, AB: University of Calgary; May 2021.
2019	Nguyen C. Multiscale Network Characterization of the Strength and Robustness of Trabecular Bone [PhD thesis]. Santa Barbara, CA: Santa Barbara, University of California; September 2019.
1995	Waanders NA. A Distraction Osteogenesis Model to Investigate the Influence of the Mechanical Environment on Bone Formation [PhD thesis]. University of Michigan; 1995.
1996	Lerner AL. Influence of Mechanical Stresses on Normal Bone Growth in the Developing Femur [PhD thesis]. University of Michigan; 1996.
1997	Richards M. Strain Environment Effects on New Bone Formation and Precursor Tissue Differentiation During Distraction [PhD thesis]. University of Michigan; 1997.
2023	Cosman MN. Trabecular and Cortical Skeletal Correlates of Locomotor Ontogeny in Pan With Comparisonsto Skeletal Variation and Adaptation in Gorilla and Pongo [PhD thesis]. University of Michigan; 2023.
2012	Hennig C. Determinants of Osteon Geometric Parameters and Their Relation With Age in Cortical Bone [Master's thesis]. University of Saskatchewan; December 2012.
2002	Wang M-Y. Quantifying Musculoskeletal Load and Adaptation: Biomechanical Consideration [PhD thesis]. University of Southern California (USC); August 2002.
2010	Beckstrom AB. Histologic and Geometric Data Challenge the Assumption of Habitual Superior-Inferior (tension-Compression) Bending Across the Chimpanzee Proximal Femur [Master's thesis]. University of Utah; August 2010.
2013	Eleazer CD. The Interaction of Mechanical Loading and Metabolic Stress on Human Cortical Bone: Testing Anthropological Assumptions Using Cross-Sectional Geometry and Histomorphology [PhD thesis]. Knoxville, University of Tennessee; August 2013.
1996	Kim Y. A Finite-Element Study of Intervertebral Cages and Spinal Bone Remodeling [PhD thesis]. University of Wisconsin – Madison; 1996.