Articular cartilage repair: basic science and clinical progress. a review of the current status and prospects

wbldb

Hunziker, E. B.¹

Articular cartilage repair: basic science and clinical progress. a review of the current status and prospects

Osteoarthritis Cartilage. June 2002;10(6):432-463

©2002 OsteoArthritis Research Society International. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Affiliations

¹M.E. Müller-Institute for Biomechanics, University of Bern, Murtenstrasse 35, P.O. Box 30, CH-3010 Bern, Switzerland
Abstract and keywords

Objective To review the basic scientific status of repair in articular cartilage tissue and to assess the efficiency of current clinical therapies instigated for the treatment of structural lesions generated therein as a result of trauma or during the course of various diseases, notably osteoarthritis (OA). Current scientific trends and possible directions for the future will also be discussed.

Design A systematic and critical analysis is undertaken, beginning with a description of the spontaneous repair responses in different types of lesion. Surgical interventions aimed at inducing repair without the use of active biologics will then be considered, followed by those involving active biologics and those drawing on autogenic and allogeneic tissue transplantation principles. Cell transplantation approaches, in particular novel tissue engineering concepts, will be critically presented. These will include growth-factor-based biological treatments and gene transfection protocols. A number of technical problems associated with repair interventions, such as tissue integration, tissue retention and the role of mechanical factors, will also be analysed.

ResultsA critical analysis of the literature reveals the existence of many novel and very promising biologically-based approaches for the induction of articular cartilage repair, the vast majority of which are still at an experimental phase of development. But prospective, double-blinded clinical trials comparing currently practiced surgical treatments have, unfortunately, not been undertaken.

Conclusion The existence of many new and encouraging biological approaches to cartilage repair justifies the future investment of time and money in this research area, particularly given the extremely high socio-economic importance of such therapeutic strategies in the prevention and treatment of these common joint diseases and traumas. Clinical epidemiological and prospective trials are, moreover, urgently needed for an objective, scientific appraisal of current therapies and future novel approaches.

Keywords: articular, cartilage, repair, review
Links

DOI: 10.1053/joca.2002.0801

PubMed: 12056848

WoS: 000176381600002
History

Received: 2001-06-19

Revised: 2001-09-07

Accepted: 2001-11-1

Cited Works (26)

Year	Entry
1993	Freed LE, Marquis JC, Nohria A, Emmanual J, Mikos AG, Langer R. Neocartilage formation in vitro and in vivo using cells cultured on synthetic biodegradable polymers. J Biomed Mater Res. January 1993;27(1):11-23.
1992	Buschmann MD, Gluzband YA, Grodzinsky AJ, Kimura JH, Hunziker EB. Chondrocytes in agarose culture synthesize a mechanically functional extracellular matrix. J Orthop Res. November 1992;10(6):745-758.
1993	Mow VC, Ateshian GA, Spilker RL. Biomechanics of diarthrodial joints: a review of twenty years of progress. J Biomech Eng. November 1993;115(4B):460-467.
1993	Setton LA, Zhu W, Mow VC. The biphasic poroviscoelastic behavior of articular cartilage: role of the surface zone in governing the compressive behavior. J Biomech. April–May 1993;26(4-5):581-592.
1994	Wakitani S, Goto T, Pineda SJ, Young RG, Mansour JM, Caplan AI, Goldberg VM. Mesenchymal cell-based repair of large, full-thickness defects of articular cartilage. J Bone Joint Surg. April 1994;76A(4):579-592.
1982	Benya PD, Shaffer JD. Dedifferentiated chondrocytes reexpress the differentiated collagen phenotype when cultured in agarose gels. Cell. August 1982;30(1):215-224.
1998	Carter DR, Beaupré GS, Giori NJ, Helms JA. Mechanobiology of skeletal regeneration. Clin Orthop Relat Res. October 1998;355(suppl):S41-S55.
1998	Freed LE, Hollander AP, Martin I, Barry JR, Langer R, Vunjak-Novakovic G. Chondrogenesis in a cell-polymer-bioreactor system. Exp Cell Res. April 10, 1998;240(1):58-65.
1999	Schachar NS, Novak K, Hurtig M, Muldrew K, McPherson R, Wohl G, Zernicke RF, McGann LE. Transplantation of cryopreserved osteochondral dowel allografts for repair of focal articular defects in an ovine model. Calcif Tiss Int. June 1999;17(6):909-919.
1999	Pittenger MF, Mackay AM, Beck SC, Jaiswal RK, Douglas R, Mosca JD, Moorman MA, Simonetti DW, Craig S, Marshak DR. Multilineage potential of adult human mesenchymal stem cells. Science. April 2, 1999;284(5411):143-147.
1997	Buckwalter JA, Mankin HJ. Articular cartilage, II: degeneration and osteoarthrosis, repair, regeneration, and transplantation. J Bone Joint Surg. April 1997;79A(4):612-632.
1999	Hunziker EB. Articular cartilage repair: are the intrinsic biological constraints undermining this process insuperable? Osteoarthritis Cartilage. January 1999;7(1):15-28.
1998	Quinn TM, Grodzinsky AJ, Hunziker EB, Sandy JD. Effects of injurious compression on matrix turnover around individual cells in calf articular cartilage explants. J Orthop Res. July 1998;16(4):490-499.
2000	Mauck RL, Soltz MA, Wang CCB, Wong DD, Chao P-HG, Valhmu WB, Hung CT, Ateshian GA. Functional tissue engineering of articular cartilage through dynamic loading of chondrocyte-seeded agarose gels. J Biomech Eng. June 2000;122(3):252-260.
1988	Gundersen HJG, Bendtsen TF, Korbo L, Marcussen N, Møller A, Nielsen K, Nyengaard JR, Pakkenberg B, Sørensen FB, Vesterby A, West MJ. Some new, simple and efficient stereological methods and their use in pathological research and diagnosis. AMPIS. May 1988;96(5):379-394.
1998	Vunjak-Novakovic G, Obradovic B, Martin I, Bursac PM, Langer R, Freed LE. Dynamic cell seeding of polymer scaffolds for cartilage tissue engineering. Biotechnol Prog. March–April 1998;14(2):193-202.
1998	Mackay AM, Beck SC, Murphy JM, Barry FP, Chichester CO, Pittenger MF. Chondrogenic differentiation of cultured human mesenchymal stem cells from marrow. Tissue Eng. Winter 1998;4(4):415-428.
2002	Hunziker EB, Quinn TM, Häuselmann H-J. Quantitative structural organization of normal adult human articular cartilage. Osteoarthritis Cartilage. July 2002;10(7):564-572.
1998	Johnstone B, Hering TM, Caplan AI, Goldberg VM, Yoo JU. In vitro chondrogenesis of bone marrow-derived mesenchymal progenitor cells. Exp Cell Res. January 10, 1998;238(1):265-272.
1994	Brittberg M, Lindahl A, Nilsson A, Ohlsson C, Isaksson O, Peterson L. Treatment of deep cartilage defects in the knee with autologous chondrocyte transplantation. NEJM. October 6, 1994;331(14):889-895.
2000	Temenoff JS, Mikos AG. Review: tissue engineering for regeneration of articular cartilage. Biomaterials. March 1, 2000;21(5):431-440.
2000	Butler DL, Goldstein SA, Guilak F. Functional tissue engineering: the role of biomechanics. J Biomech Eng. December 2000;122(6):570-575.
1993	Shapiro F, Koide S, Glimcher MJ. Cell origin and differentiation in the repair of full-thickness defects of articular cartilage. J Bone Joint Surg. April 1993;75A(4):532-553.
1991	Caplan AI. Mesenchymal stem cells. J Orthop Res. September 1991;9(5):641-650.
1999	Vunjak-Novakovic G, Martin I, Obradovic B, Treppo S, Grodzinsky AJ, Langer R, Freed LE. Bioreactor cultivation conditions modulate the composition and mechanical properties of tissue-engineered cartilage. J Orthop Res. January 1999;17(1):130-138.
1998	Rahfoth B, Weisser J, Sternkopf F, Aigner T, von der Mark K, Bräuer R. Transplantation of allograft chondrocytes embedded in agarose gel into cartilage defects of rabbits. Osteoarthritis Cartilage. 1998;5(1):50-65.

Cited By (75)

Year	Entry
2004	Awad HA, Wickham MQ, Leddy HA, Gimble JM, Guilak F. Chondrogenic differentiation of adipose-derived adult stem cells in agarose, alginate, and gelatin scaffolds. Biomaterials. July 2004;25(16):3211-3222.
2020	Bez M, Pelled G, Gazit D. BMP gene delivery for skeletal tissue regeneration. Bone. August 2020;137:115449.
2021	Dou Z, Muder D, Baroncelli M, Bendre A, Gkourogianni A, Ottosson L, Vedung T, Nilsson O. Rat perichondrium transplanted to articular cartilage defects forms articular-like, hyaline cartilage. Bone. October 2021;151:116035.
2004	Knutsen G, Engebretsen L, Ludvigsen TC, Drogset JO, Grøntvedt T, Solheim E, Strand T, Roberts S, Isaksen V, Johansen O. Autologous chondrocyte implantation compared with microfracture in the knee: a randomized trial. J Bone Joint Surg. March 2004;86A(3):455-464.
2004	Urban JPG, Smith S, Fairbank JCT. Nutrition of the intervertebral disc. Spine. December 1, 2004;29(23):2700-2709.
2015	Lakin BA. Developing a Cationic Contrast Agent for Computed Tomographic Imaging of Articular Cartilage and Synthetic Biolubricants for Early Diagnosis and Treatment of Osteoarthritis [PhD thesis]. Boston University; 2015.
2019	Burkov IS. 3D Analysis of the Hip Joint for the Prediction of Osteoarthritis [PhD thesis]. Cambridge, UK: University of Cambridge; March 2019.
2017	Younesi M. Biofabrication of Collageneous Constructs Via Electrochemical Compaction Process for Musculoskeletal Tissue Engineering [PhD thesis]. Cleveland, OH: Case Western Reserve University; 2017.
2017	Wahlquist JA. Zonal Articular Cartilage Possesses Complex Mechanical Behavior Spanning Multiple Length Scales: Dependence on Chemical Heterogeneity, Anisotropy, and Microstructure [PhD thesis]. Boulder, CO: University of Colorado; 2017.
2020	Barthold JE. Development of Extracellular Matrix Based Biomaterials for Articular Cartilage Repair [PhD thesis]. University of Colorado; 2020.
2007	Wan Q. Fundamental Theoretical and Experimental Studies for Applications Toward Functional Tissue Engineering of Articular Cartilage [PhD thesis]. Columbia University; 2007.
2011	Moffat KL. Biomimetic Nanofiber Scaffold Design for Tendon-to-Bone Interface Tissue Engineering [PhD thesis]. Columbia University; 2011.
2012	Khanarian NT. Scaffold Design and Optimization for Osteochondral Interface Tissue Engineering [PhD thesis]. Columbia University; 2012.
2016	Boushell MK. Scaffold Design and Optimization for Integrative Cartilage Repair [PhD thesis]. Columbia University; 2016.
2017	Nims RJ. Optimizing Cartilage Tissue Engineering Through Computational Growth Models and Experimental Culture Protocols [PhD thesis]. Columbia University; 2017.
2020	Mosher CZ. Interface Scaffold Design Principles for Integrative Cartilage Regeneration [PhD thesis]. Columbia University; 2020.
2019	Phillips ER. Cartilage Molecular Engineering Using Biomimetic Proteoglycans [PhD thesis]. Drexel University; March 2019.
2020	Han B. Decorin Regulates the Structure and Biomechanical Functions of Articular Cartilage Extracellular Matrix in Health and Disease [PhD thesis]. Drexel University; October 2020.
2005	Betre H. Controlled Intra-Articular Drug Delivery System Based on Thermally Responsive Biopolymers [PhD thesis]. Duke University; 2005.
2007	Nettles DL. Artificial Neural Network Modeling of Crosslinked Elastin -Like Polypeptide Formulations Parameters Effects on Physical Properties and Cellular Interactions for Cartilage Tissue Engineering [PhD thesis]. Duke University; 2007.
2009	Moutos FT. Biomimetic Composite Scaffolds for the Functional Tissue Engineering of Articular Cartilage [PhD thesis]. Duke University; 2009.
2012	Diekman BO. Stem Cell-Based Strategies to Study, Prevent, and Treat Cartilage Injury and Osteoarthritis [PhD thesis]. Duke University; 2012.
2016	Glass KA. Combined Gene Therapy and Functional Tissue Engineering for the Treatment of Osteoarthritis [PhD thesis]. Duke University; 2016.
2016	Thakore PI. Targeted Gene Repression Technologies for Regenerative Medicine, Genomics, and Gene Therapy [PhD thesis]. Duke University; 2016.
2018	O'Connor SK. Osteochondral Tissue Engineering With Induced Pluripotent Stem Cells [PhD thesis]. Duke University; 2018.
2014	Studer D. Engineering Phenotypically Stable Cartilage [PhD thesis]. Swiss Federal Institute of Technology Zürich; 2014.
2018	Cavalli E. Cell‐based Injectable Therapies for Cartilage Repair [PhD thesis]. Swiss Federal Institute of Technology Zürich; 2018.
2020	Levinson CSJ. From Bedside to Bench and Back: Translatable Approaches for Cartilage Repair [PhD thesis]. Swiss Federal Institute of Technology Zürich; 2020.
2004	Sitterle VB. Photoactivated Fixation of Cartilage Tissue [PhD thesis]. Atlanta, GA: Georgia Institute of Technology; August 2004.
2006	Gemmiti CV. Effect of Fluid Flow on Tissue-Engineered Cartilage in a Novel Bioreactor [PhD thesis]. Atlanta, GA: Georgia Institute of Technology; December 2006.
2007	Connelly JT. Regulatory Mechanisms in the Chondrogenesis of Mesenchymal Progenitors: The Roles of Cyclic Tensile Loading and Cell-Matrix Interactions [PhD thesis]. Atlanta, GA: Georgia Institute of Technology; August 2007.
2009	Kolambkar YM. Electrospun Nanofiber Meshes for the Functional Repair of Bone Defects [PhD thesis]. Atlanta, GA: Georgia Institute of Technology; December 2009.
2014	Thote T. Evaluation of Therapeutics Strategies for Osteoarthritis Using Contrast Based CT Imaging Atlanta, GA: Georgia Institute of Technology; August 2014.
2011	Moodie J. Destabilisation of the Medial Meniscus: Imaging and Mechanics of a Murine Surgical Osteoarthritis Model [PhD thesis]. Imperial College London; August 2011.
2015	Beck EC. Development of Chondroinductive Hydrogel Pastes from Naturally Derived Cartilage Matrix [PhD thesis]. Lawrence, KS: University of Kansas; 2015.
2013	Vernon LL. Articular Cartilage Response Following Impact Injury [PhD thesis]. University of Miami; August 2013.
2006	Stevens AL. Mechanical Injury and Inflammatory Cytokines Affect Cartilage Integrity and Tissue Homeostasis: A Mass Spectrometric Analysis of Proteins With Relevance to Arthritis [PhD thesis]. Cambridge, MA: Massachusetts Institute of Technology; September 2006.
2010	Lee H-Y. Ultrastructure and Nanomechanical Properties of Aggrecan from Native Cartilage and Engineered Tissue [PhD thesis]. Cambridge, MA: Massachusetts Institute of Technology; June 2010.
2010	Miller RE. In Vitro and in Vivo Growth Factor Delivery to Chondrocytes and Bone-Marrow-Derived Stromal Cells in Cartilage and in Self-Assembling Peptide Scaffolds [PhD thesis]. Cambridge, MA: Massachusetts Institute of Technology; June 2010.
2016	Liebesny PH. Single-Dose Growth Factor Treatments to Enhance Cell Recruitment and Neotissue Integration in an Augmented Microfracture Cartilage Repair Model [PhD thesis]. Cambridge, MA: Massachusetts Institute of Technology; June 2016.
2017	Ibañez JR. Use of Synthetic Solid Scaffolds to Mechanically Support a Chondrocyte-Seeded Peptide Hydrogel for Articular Cartilage Repair [Master's thesis]. Cambridge, MA: Massachusetts Institute of Technology; June 2017.
2011	Changoor A. Electromechanical and Polarization Microscopy Evaluation of Cartilage Repair and Degeneration [PhD thesis]. École polytechnique de Montréal; January 2011.
2017	Dwivedi G. Identification of in Situ Progenitor Cell Features Contributing to Cartilage Repair and Strategies for Cartilage Repair Augmentation [PhD thesis]. École polytechnique de Montréal; April 2017.
2009	Fan CY. Effects of Intermittent Static and Dynamic Tension on Articular Chondrocytes in High Density Culture [Master's thesis]. Queen's University; March 2009.
2009	McGregor AJ. A Method to Improve Cartilage Integration [Master's thesis]. Queen's University; December 2009.
2010	Usprech JF. A Therapeutic Dose of Adenosine Triphosphate (ATP) for Cartilage Tissue Engineering [Master's thesis]. Queen's University; September 2010.
2011	Bow JK. Using Adenosine Triphosphate (ATP) as a Substitute for Mechanical Stimulation for Tissue Engineering Applications [Master's thesis]. Queen's University; January 2011.
2012	Kaupp JA. Simulated Joint Loading Enhances the Expression of of Superficial Zone Markers in Tissue Engineered Cartilage Constructs [PhD thesis]. Queen's University; February 2012.
2012	Khan AA. Effects of Additional Sodium Bicarbonate on Extra/intra Cellular Factors in a Continuous Flow Bioreactor for the Production of Tissue Engineered Articular Cartilage [PhD thesis]. Queen's University; October 2012.
2018	Neville SR. Methods for Improving Ability to Investigate the Effectiveness of Non-Invasive Treatment Strategies for Medial Knee OA [Master's thesis]. Queen's University; September 2018.
2010	Schrobback K. In Vitro Cultivation of Adult Human Chondrocytes: Importance of Culture System, Oxygen and Zonal Differences [PhD thesis]. Queensland University of Technology; 2010.
2015	Babur BK. Utilizing Micropellets as Building Blocks in Cartilage Tissue Engineering [PhD thesis]. Queensland University of Technology; February 2015.
2018	Arabshahi Z. New Mechanical Indentation Framework for Functional Assessment of Articular Cartilage [PhD thesis]. Queensland University of Technology; 2018.
2020	Music E. Optimisation of Methods for Driving Chondrogenesis of Human and Ovine Bone Marrow–derived Stromal Cells [PhD thesis]. Queensland University of Technology; 2020.
2005	Scott CC. Interferometry of Chondrocytes and Impact of Articular Cartilage [PhD thesis]. Houston, TX: Rice University; August 2005.
2006	Leipzig ND. Growth Factor Effects on Single Chondrocyte Biomechanics and Gene Expression [PhD thesis]. Houston, TX: Rice University; April 2006.
2008	Revell CM. Characterization of Chondrocytic Differentiation and Optimization of a Self-Assembling Process for Tissue Engineering of Articular Cartilage [PhD thesis]. Houston, TX: Rice University; April 2008.
2018	Arvayo AL. Rapid and Durable Integration of Articular Cartilage Via Photochemical Bonding: Benchtop Optimization, in-Vitro Analysis & Preclinical Model [PhD thesis]. Stanford University; June 2018.
2016	Vazão de Almeida HM. Cartilage Extracellular Matrix-Derived Scaffolds for Joint Regeneration [PhD thesis]. Trinity College Dublin; January 2016.
2017	Critchley SE. Towards 3D Bioprinting of Anatomically Accurate, Mechanically Reinforced Cartilage Templates for Biological Joint Resurfacing [PhD thesis]. Trinity College Dublin; 2017.
2020	Matheson AR. Proteoglycan-4 in Equine Joint Disease, Exercise, and in Vitro Cartilage Repair [PhD thesis]. Calgary, AB: University of Calgary; May 2020.
2004	Kazakia GJ. Development, Analysis, and Imaging of a Tissue Engineered Trabecular Bone Substitute [PhD thesis]. Berkeley, CA: Berkeley, University of California; 2004.
2014	Hadidi P. Enhancing the Biochemical and Mechanical Properties of a Self-Assembling Scaffold-Free Tissue Engineered Knee Meniscus [PhD thesis]. Davis, University of California; 2014.
2014	Murphy MK. Engineering Functional Cartilage for the Temporomandibular Joint [PhD thesis]. Davis, University of California; 2014.
2005	Klein TJ. Cartilage Tissue Engineering: Biophysical Modulation of Functional Depth-Dependent Properties [PhD thesis]. San Diego (UCSD), University of California; 2005.
2005	McGowan KB. Enhancement of Integrative Cartilage Repair by Manipulation of Extracellular Matrix [PhD thesis]. San Diego (UCSD), University of California; 2005.
2009	Hsieh-Bonassera ND. Cartilage Tissue Engineering With Human Chondrocytes from Osteoarthritic Knees and a Semi-Permeable Membrane [PhD thesis]. San Diego (UCSD), University of California; 2009.
2016	Park M. Prevention and Treatment of Post-Traumatic Osteoarthritis [PhD thesis]. University of Delaware; 2016.
2018	Zhou Y. Intracellular Calcium Signaling of Chondrocytes and the Treatment of Osteoarthritis [PhD thesis]. University of Delaware; 2018.
2019	David MA. Local, Intra-Articular Delivery of Zoledronic Acid as a Disease-Modifying Therapeutic for Post-Traumatic Osteoarthritis [PhD thesis]. University of Delaware; 2019.
2011	Trutiak N. Regional Biomechanical Properties of the Articular Surface, in the Human Distal Femur, in Health and Disease [Master's thesis]. University of Guelph; May 2011.
2017	Mohanraj B. High Throughput and Mechano-Active Platforms to Promote Cartilage Regeneration and Repair [PhD thesis]. Philadelphia, PA: University of Pennsylvania; 2017.
2013	Harris MD. The Geometry and Biomechanics of Normal and Pathomorphologic Human Hips [PhD thesis]. University of Utah; August 2013.
2014	Pourmohammadali H. Mechanical and Hydromechanical Stimulation of Chondrocytes for Articular Cartilage Tissue Engineering [PhD thesis]. University of Waterloo; 2014.
2010	Wartella KA. Effect of Mechanical Stimulation on Mesenchymal Stem Cell Seeded Cartilage Constructs [PhD thesis]. Richmond, VA: Virginia Commonwealth University; August 2010.