Concussion in professional football: helmet testing to assess impact performance—Part 11

wbldb

Pellman, Elliot J.^1,2; Viano, David C.^1,3; Withnall, Chris⁴; Shewchenko, Nick⁴; Bir, Cynthia A.⁵; Halstead, P. David^6,7

Concussion in professional football: helmet testing to assess impact performance—Part 11

Neurosurgery. January 2006;58(1):78-95

Affiliations

¹Mild Traumatic Brain Injury Committee, National Football League, New York, New York

²ProHEALTH Care Associates, LLP, Lake Success, New York

³ProBiomechanics, LLC, Bloomfield Hills, Michigan

⁴Biokinetics and Associates, Ltd., Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

⁵Sport Biomechanics Laboratory, Bioengineering Center, Wayne State University, Detroit, Michigan

⁶National Operating Committee on Standards for Athletic Equipment, Overland Park, Kansas

⁷University of Tennessee, College of Engineering, Sports Biomechanics, Impact Research Lab, Knoxville, Tennessee
Abstract and keywords

Objective: National Football League (NFL) concussions occur at an impact velocity of 9.3 ± 1.9 m/s (20.8 ± 4.2 mph) oblique on the facemask, side, and back of the helmet. There is a need for new testing to evaluate helmet performance for impacts causing concussion. This study provides background on new testing methods that form a basis for supplemental National Operating Committee on Standards for Athletic Equipment (NOCSAE) helmet standards.

Methods: First, pendulum impacts were used to simulate 7.4 and 9.3 m/s impacts causing concussion in NFL players. An instrumented Hybrid III head was helmeted and supported on the neck, which was fixed to a sliding table for frontal and lateral impacts. Second, a linear pneumatic impactor was used to evaluate helmets at 9.3 m/s and an elite impact condition at 11.2 m/s. The upper torso of the Hybrid III dummy was used. It allowed interactions with shoulder pads and other equipment. The severity of the head responses was measured by a severity index, translational and rotational acceleration, and other biomechanical responses. High-speed videos of the helmet kinematics were also recorded. The tests were evaluated for their similarity to conditions causing NFL concussions. Finally, a new linear impactor was developed for use by NOCSAE.

Results: The pendulum test closely simulated the conditions causing concussion in NFL players. Newer helmet designs and padding reduced the risk of concussion in 7.4 and 9.3 m/s impacts oblique on the facemask and lateral on the helmet shell. The linear impactor provided a broader speed range for helmet testing and more interactions with safety equipment. NOCSAE has prepared a draft supplemental standard for the 7.4 and 9.3 m/s impacts using a newly designed pneumatic impactor. No helmet designs currently address the elite impact condition at 11.2 m/s, as padding bottoms out and head responses dramatically increase.

Conclusions: The proposed NOCSAE standard is the first to address helmet performance in reducing concussion risks in football. Helmet performance has improved with thicker padding and fuller coverage by the shell. However, there remains a challenge for innovative designs that reduce risks in the 11.2 m/s elite impact condition.

Keywords: Concussion, Helmets, Protective headgear, Recreation and sport, Sports equipment
Links

DOI: 10.1227/01.NEU.0000196265.35238.7C

PubMed: 16385332

WoS: 000234453800017
History

Received: 2005-04-08

Accepted: 2005-10-31

Cited Works (15)

Year	Entry
1975	Padgaonkar AJ, Krieger KW, King AI. Measurement of angular acceleration of a rigid body using linear accelerometers. J Appl Mech. September 1975;42(3):552-556.
2005	Viano DC, Pellman EJ. Concussion in professional football: biomechanics of the striking player: part 8. Neurosurgery. February 2005;56(2):266-278.
1968	Gurdjian ES, Hodgson VR, Thomas LM, Patrick LM. Significance of relative movements of scalp, skull, and intracranial contents during impact injury of the head. J Neurosurg. July 1968;29(1):70-72.
1966	Gadd CW. Use of a weighted-impulse criterion for estimating injury hazard. In: Proceedings of the 10th Stapp Car Crash Conference. November 8-9, 1966; Hollomon Air Force Base, NM. Warrendale, PA: Society of Automotive Engineers:164-174. SAE 660793.
2003	Pellman EJ. Background on the National Football League's research on concussion in professional football. Neurosurgery. October 2003;53(4):797-798.
1972	Hodgson VR, Mason MW, Thomas LM. Head model for impact. In: Proceedings of the 16th Stapp Car Crash Conference. November 8-10, 1972; Detroit, MI. Warrendale, PA: Society of Automotive Engineers:1-13. SAE 720969.
2003	Pellman EJ, Viano DC, Tucker AM, Casson IR. Concussion in professional football: location and direction of helmet impacts—part 2. Neurosurgery. December 2003;53(6):1328-1341.
1975	Hodgson VR. National Operating Committee on Standards for Athletic Equipment football helmet certification program. Med Sci Sports. F 1975;7(2):225-232.
2000	Newman JA, Shewchenko N, Welbourne E. A proposed new biomechanical head injury assessment function: the maximum power index. Stapp Car Crash J. 2000;44:215-247. SAE 2000-01-SC16.
1980	Hodgson VR, Thomas LM. Mechanisms of cervical spine injury during impact to the protected head. In: Proceedings of the 24th Stapp Car Crash Conference. October 15-17, 1980; Troy, MI. Warrendale, PA: Society of Automotive Engineers:17-42. SAE 801300.
1989	Viano DC, Lau IV, Asbury C, King AI, Begeman P. Biomechanics of the human chest, abdomen, and pelvis in lateral impact. Accid Anal Prev. 1989;21(6):553-574.
1978	Mertz HJ, Hodgson VR, Thomas LM, Nyquist GW. An assessment of compressive neck loads under injury-producing conditions. Phys Sportsmed. December 1978;6(11):95-106.
2003	Pellman EJ, Viano DC, Tucker A, Casson IR, Waeckerle JF. Concussion in professional football: reconstruction of game impacts and injuries. Neurosurgery. October 2003;53(4):799-814.
1970	Hodgson VR, Thomas LM, Prasad P. Testing the validity and limitations of the severity index. In: Proceedings of the 14th Stapp Car Crash Conference. November 17-18, 1970; Ann Arbor, MI. Warrendale, PA: Society of Automotive Engineers:169-187. SAE 700901.
1966	Hodgson VR, Gurdjian ES, Thomas LM. Experimental skull deformation and brain displacement demonstrated by flash X-ray technique. J Neurosurg. November 1966;25(5):549-552.

Cited By (40)

Year	Entry
2007	Craig MJ, Bir CA, Viano DC. Jaw loading response of the human relative to current ATDs. In: Proceedings of the 35th International Workshop on Human Subjects for Biomechanical Research. 2007.71-84.
2012	Post A, Oeur A, Hoshizaki B, Gilchrist MD. The influence of centric and non‐centric impacts to American football helmets on the correlation between commonly used metrics in brain injury research. In: Proceedings of the 2012 International IRCOBI Conference on the Biomechanics of Injury. September 12-14, 2012; Dublin, Ireland.419-429.
2014	Walsh ES, Kendall M, Hoshizaki TB, Gilchrist MD. Dynamic impact response and predicted brain tissue deformation comparisons for an impacted Hybrid III headform with and without a neckform and torso masses. In: Proceedings of the 2014 International IRCOBI Conference on the Biomechanics of Injury. September 10-12, 2014; Berlin, Germany.55-61.
2014	Ouckama R, Pearsall DJ. Projectile impact testing of ice hockey helmets: headform kinematics and dynamic measurement of localized pressure distribution. In: Proceedings of the 2014 International IRCOBI Conference on the Biomechanics of Injury. September 10-12, 2014; Berlin, Germany.62-71.
2018	Bland ML, McNally C, Rowson S. Headform and neck effects on dynamic response in bicycle helmet oblique impact testing. In: Proceedings of the 2018 International IRCOBI Conference on the Biomechanics of Injury. September 12-14, 2018; Athens, Greece.413-423.
2020	Levy Y, Gallone MB, Bian K, McDougall K, Ouckama R, Mao H. Using a strain-based computational approach for ice hockey helmet performance evaluation. In: Proceedings of the 2020 International IRCOBI Conference on the Biomechanics of Injury. 2020; Munich, Germany.569-580.
2018	Lessley DJ, Kent RW, Funk JR, Sherwood CP, Cormier JM, Crandall JR, Arbogast KB, Myers BS. Video analysis of reported concussion events in the National Football League during the 2015-2016 and 2016-2017 seasons. Am J Sports Med. December 2018;46(14):3502-3510.
2012	Viano DC, Withnall C, Wonnacott M. Effect of mouthguards on head responses and mandible forces in football helmet impacts. Ann Biomed Eng. January 2012;40(1):47-69.
2012	Viano DC, Withnall C, Wonnacott M. Football helmet drop tests on different fields using an instrumented Hybrid III head. Ann Biomed Eng. January 2012;40(1):97-105.
2012	Viano DC, Withnall C, Halstead D. Impact performance of modern football helmets. Ann Biomed Eng. January 2012;40(1):160-174.
2012	Viano DC, Halstead D. Change in size and impact performance of football helmets from the 1970s to 2010. Ann Biomed Eng. January 2012;40(1):175-184.
2012	Beckwith JG, Greenwald RM, Chu JJ. Measuring head kinematics in football: correlation between the head impact telemetry system and Hybrid III headform. Ann Biomed Eng. January 2012;40(1):237-248.
2020	Decker W, Baker A, Ye X, Brown P, Stitzel J, Gayzik FS. Development and multi-scale validation of a finite element football helmet model. Ann Biomed Eng. January 2020;48(1):258-270.
2013	Jadischke R, Viano DC, Dau N, King AI, McCarthy J. On the accuracy of the Head Impact Telemetry (HIT) System used in football helmets. J Biomech. September 3, 2013;46(13):2310.
2021	Bruneau DA, Cronin DS. Brain response of a computational head model for prescribed skull kinematics and simulated football helmet impact boundary conditions. J Mech Behav Biomed Mater. March 2021;115:104299.
2006	Viano DC, Pellman EJ, Withnall C, Shewchenko N. Concussion in professional football: performance of newer helmets in reconstructed game impacts: part 13. Neurosurgery. September 2006;59(3):591-606.
2007	Viano DC, Casson IR, Pellman EJ. Concussion in professional football: biomechanics of the struck player—Part 14. Neurosurgery. August 2007;61(2):313-327.
2009	Rousseau P, Hoshizaki TB. The influence of deflection and neck compliance on the impact dynamics of a Hybrid III headform. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part P-J Sports Eng Tech. 2009;223(1):89-97.
2011	Walsh ES, Rousseau P, Hoshizaki TB. The influence of impact location and angle on the dynamic impact response of a Hybrid III headform. Sports Eng. March 2011;13(3):135-143.
2016	Akhbari B. Biomechanical Analyses of Head Acceleration During Contact Sports and Ankle Joint Complex Injury [Master's thesis]. Lawrence, KS: University of Kansas; 2016.
2020	McGillivray K. Comparison of Innovated Thermoplastic Polyurethane and Commercial Helmet Lining Technology in Mitigating Concussions as Measured by Linear Accelerations and Risk of Head Injury During Simulated Horizontal Impacts to the Head [Master's thesis]. Thunder Bay, ON: Lakehead University; 2020.
2022	LeMaire CB. Tunable Passive Shock and Vibration Isolators for Rotational Isolation [Master's thesis]. Louisiana State University; August 2022.
2018	Klein MJ. Development and Validation of a Surrogate Ankle for Biomechanical Testing of Footwear [Master's thesis]. East Lansing, MI: Michigan State University; 2018.
2022	Wynn GF. Repeatability of a Novel Prototype Surrogate Neck Model Developed for Omni-Directional Head Impacts [Master's thesis]. Edmonton, AB: University of Alberta; 2022.
2011	Coulson NR. The Influence of Impact Mass, Inbound Velocity and System Compliance on the Dynamic Response of a Hybrid III Head Form [Master's thesis]. Ottawa, ON: University of Ottawa; 2011.
2012	Karton C. The Effect of Inbound Mass on the Dynamic Response of the Hybrid III Headform and Brain Tissue Deformation [Master's thesis]. Ottawa, ON: University of Ottawa; November 2012.
2012	Oeur A. An Analysis of Head Impact Angle on the Dynamic Response of a Hybrid III Headform and Brain Tissue Deformation [Master's thesis]. Ottawa, ON: University of Ottawa; December 2012.
2018	Oeur RA. The Effects of Reconstructed Head Impact Event Parameters on Risk of Sport Related Concussions [PhD thesis]. Ottawa, ON: University of Ottawa; 2018.
2018	Taylor K. The Use of Decoupling Structures in Helmet Liners to Reduce Maximum Principal Brain Tissue Strain for Head Impacts [PhD thesis]. University of Ottawa; 2018.
2019	Bruneau D. Investigation of Head and Brain Response in Football Helmet Impacts Using a Finite Element Model of the Head and Neck With Active Muscle [Master's thesis]. University of Waterloo; 2019.
2006	McNeely DE III. Analysis of Force-Limiting Capabilities of Football Neck Collars [Master's thesis]. Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University; May 1, 2006.
2014	Daniel RW II. Evaluation of Football Safety Techniques Utilizing Biomechanical Measurements [PhD thesis]. Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University; June 3, 2014.
2015	Cobb BR. Laboratory and Field Studies in Sports-Related Brain Injury [PhD thesis]. Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University; March 25, 2015.
2017	Sproule DW. Evaluation of the Biomechanical Performance of Youth Football Helmets [Master's thesis]. Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University; March 30, 2017.
2019	Bland ML. Assessing the Efficacy of Bicycle Helmets in Reducing Risk of Head Injury [PhD thesis]. Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University; March 28, 2019.
2019	Campolettano ET. Quantifying Postural Control, Concussion Risk, and Helmet Performance in Youth Football [PhD thesis]. Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University; March 27, 2019.
2007	Craig MJ. Biomechanics of Jaw Loading in Football Helmet Impacts [PhD thesis]. Detroit, MI: Wayne State University; 2007.
2016	Brooks JS. The Use of P3b as an Indicator of Neurophysiologic Change from Subconcussive Impacts in Football Players [Master's thesis]. University of Western Ontario; 2016.
2021	Islam SU. Significance of the Neck in Concussive Head Impacts: A Computational Approach [Master's thesis]. University of Western Ontario; 2021.
2020	Decker WB. Utilizing Simplified Human Body and Countermeasure Models for Head Injury Prevention in Contact and Motor Sports [PhD thesis]. Winston-Salem, NC: Wake Forest University; September 2020.