When testing for the effects of bone orientation on mode I fracture toughness, compact tension specimens are grooved with a V-notch to provide a crack guide. The effect of grooving on the expressions for the critical stress intensity factor (K_c) and the critical strain energy release rate (G_c) for mode I fracture toughness was investigated. Experiments were performed using grooved and ungrooved bovine compact tension specimens. The results indicate that the standard expression used to determine Kc for a compact tension specimen requires modification. The thickness (B) must be modified to account for the thickness between the grooves (B_n). The thickness used in the standard expression is replaced by an effective thickness written as (BB_n)^0.5. It was also found that the thickness between the grooves should be used in the standard formula for G_c.