Automobile driver fatalities in frontal impacts: air bags compared with manual belts

wbldb

Zador, Paul L.¹; Ciccone, Michael A.¹

Automobile driver fatalities in frontal impacts: air bags compared with manual belts

Am J Public Health. May 1993;83(5):661-666

Affiliations

¹Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, Arlington, Va
Abstract

Objectives: The effectiveness of air bags was estimated in this study by comparing driver fatalities in frontal crashes with driver fatalities in nonfrontal crashes, for cars with air bags and manual belts and cars with manual belts only.

Methods: Fatal Accident Reporting System data for drivers fatally injured during 1985 to 1991 in 1985 to 1991 model year cars that were equipped with air bags in or before model year 1991 were analyzed.

Results: Driver fatalities in frontal crashes in air bag cars were 28% lower than those in comparable cars with manual belts only. This percentage was used for estimating the overall fatality reduction in air bag cars. The reduction was greater in large cars (50%) than in midsize cars (19%) or in small cars (14%). Air bags reduced driver fatalities in frontal crashes involving ejection by about 9%. Fatalities in frontal crashes among drivers who were reportedly using manual belts at the time of the crash were reduced by about 15%. The comparable reduction among drivers who were reportedly not using manual belts was 31%.

Conclusion: It was estimated that air bags reduced the total number of all driver fatalities by about 19%.
Links

DOI: 10.2105/AJPH.83.5.661

PubMed: 8484445

PubMedCentral: PMC1694686

WoS: A1993LB82500008
History

Accepted: 1993-01-08

Cited Works (4)

Year	Entry
1991	Evans L. Traffic Safety and the Driver. New York, NY: Van Nostrand Reinhold; 1991.
1974	Baker SP, O'Neill B, Haddon W Jr, Long WB. The injury severity score: a method for describing patients with multiple injuries and evaluating emergency care. J Trauma. March 1974;14(3):187-196.
1990	Reinfurt DW, St. Cyr CL, Hunter WW. Usage patterns and misuse rates of automatic seat belts by system type. In: 34th Annual Proceedings, Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine (AAAM). October 1-3, 1990; Scottsdale, AZ.163-179.
1976	Mohan D, Zador P, O’Neill B, Ginsburg M. Air bags and lap/shoulder belts: a comparison of their effectiveness in real world, frontal crashes. In: 20th Annual Proceedings, Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine (AAAM). November 1-3, 1976; Atlanta, GA.315-335.

Cited By (28)

Year	Entry
2001	Levitt SD, Porter J. Sample selection in the estimation of air bag and seat belt effectiveness. Rev Econ Stat. 2001;83(4):603-615.
1993	Evans L. Response to discussions driver injury and fatality risk in two-car crashes versus mass ratio inferred using Newtonian mechanics. In: 37th Annual Proceedings, Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine (AAAM). November 4-6, 1993; San Antonio, TX.341-343.
1998	Cirera E, Plasència A, Ferrando J, Seguí-Gomez M. Factors associated with severity and hospital admission of motor-vehicle injury cases in a southern European urban area. In: 42nd Annual Proceedings, Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine (AAAM). October 5-7, 1998; Charlottesville, VA.287-302.
2000	Segui-Gomez M, Graham JD. Patterns of injury among drivers hospitalized in Level-I trauma centers: have frontal airbags made a difference? In: 44th Annual Proceedings, Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine (AAAM). October 2-4, 2000; Chicago, IL.
1994	Huelke DF, Moore JL, Compton TW, Samuels J, Levine RS. Upper extremity injuries related to air bag deployments. In: Advances in Occupant Restraint Technologies: Joint AAAM-IRCOBI Special Session. September 22, 1994; Lyon, France.55-78.
1994	Augenstein J, Perdeck E, Stratton J, Digges K, Lombardo L, Malliaris A. Injuries sustained by air bag occupants in frontal crashes. In: Proceedings of the 14th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles (ESV). May 23-26, 1994; Munich, Germany.641-648.
1994	Evans L. Car size and safety: a review focused on identifying causative factors. In: Proceedings of the 14th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles (ESV). May 23-26, 1994; Munich, Germany.721-733.
1996	Huelke DF, Reed RT. Cranial-vertebral fractures and dislocations associated with steering wheel airbag deployment. In: Proceedings of the 15th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles (ESV). May 13-16, 1996; Melbourne, Australia.110-115.
1998	Winston FK, Durbin DR, Bents FD, Werner JV, Bhatia E, Menon RA, Arbogast KB. A comprehensive surveillance system to investigate targeted issues in child occupant protection. In: Proceedings of the 16th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles (ESV). May 31–June 4, 1998; Windsor, Ontario, Canada.1291-1297.
2009	Braver ER, McCartt AT, Sherwood CP, Fraade-Blanar L, Scerbo M. How often do front airbags fail to deploy in fatal frontal crashes? In: Proceedings of the 21st International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles (ESV). June 15-18, 2009; Stuttgart, Germany.
1995	Grafton AJ, Galer Flyte MD, King PD, Jackson MR. Pre-crash sensing of occupant characteristics and position: enhancing secondary safety system performance. In: Proceedings of the 1995 International IRCOBI Conference on the Biomechanics of Impact. September 13-15, 1995; Brunnen, Switzerland.311-323.
1996	Dischinger PC, Ho SM, Kerns TJ, Brennan P. Patterns of injury in frontal collisions with and without airbags. In: Proceedings of the 1996 International IRCOBI Conference on the Biomechanics of Impact. September 11-13, 1996; Dublin, Ireland.311-319.
1994	Rouhana SW, Webb SR, Wooley RG, McCleary JD, Wood FD, Salva DB. Investigation into the noise associated with air bag deployment, I: measurement technique and parameter study. In: Proceedings of the 38th Stapp Car Crash Conference. October 31–November 2, 1994; Fort Lauderdale, FL. Warrendale, PA: Society of Automotive Engineers:191-212. SAE 942218.
1994	Blower D, Campbell KL. Comparison of occupant restraints based on injury-producing contact rates. In: Proceedings of the 38th Stapp Car Crash Conference. October 31–November 2, 1994; Fort Lauderdale, FL. Warrendale, PA: Society of Automotive Engineers:215-224. SAE 942219.
1998	Rouhana SW, Webb SR, Dunn VC. Investigation into the noise associated with airbag deployment, II: injury risk study using a mathematical model of the human ear. In: Proceedings of the 42nd Stapp Car Crash Conference. November 2-4, 1998; Tempa, AZ. Warrendale, PA: Society of Automotive Engineers:267-. SAE 983162.
1994	Evans L. Driver injury and fatality risk in two-car crashes versus mass ratio inferred using Newtonian mechanics. Accid Anal Prev. October 1994;26(5):609-616.
2002	Bédard M, H.Guyatt G, Stones MJ, Hirdes JP. The independent contribution of driver, crash, and vehicle characteristics to driver fatalities. Accid Anal Prev. November 2002;34(6):717-727.
2001	Crandall CS, Olson LM, Sklar DP. Mortality reduction with air bag and seat belt use in head-on passenger car collisions. Am J Epidemiol. February 1, 2001;153(3):219-224.
2002	Cummings P, McKnight B, Rivara FP, Grossman DC. Association of driver air bags with driver fatality: a matched cohort study. BMJ. May 11, 2002;324(7346):1119-1122.
2000	Richter M, Otte D, Pohlemann T, Krettek C, Blauth M. Whiplash-type neck distortion in restrained car drivers: frequency, causes and long-term results. Eur Spine J. April 2000;9(2):109-117.
1997	Braver ER, Ferguson SA, Greene MA, Lund AK. Reductions in deaths in frontal crashes among right front passengers in vehicles equipped with passenger air bags. JAMA. November 5, 1997;278(17):1437-1439.
2001	Richter M, Thermann H, Wippermann B, Otte D, Schratt H-E, Tscherne H. Foot fractures in restrained front seat car occupants: a long-term study over twenty-three years. J Orthop Trauma. May 2001;15(4):287-293.
1995	Lund AK, Ferguson SA. Driver fatalities in 1985-1993 cars with airbags. J Trauma. April 1995;38(4):469-475.
1995	Huelke DF, Moore JL, Compton TW, Samuels J, Levine RS. Upper extremity injuries related to airbag deployments. J Trauma. April 1995;38(4):482-488.
1995	Burgess AR, Dischinger PC, O'Quinn TD, Schmidhauser CB. Lower extremity injuries in drivers of airbag-equipped automobiles: clinical and crash reconstruction correlations. J Trauma. April 1995;38(4):509-516.
1996	Loo GT, Siegel JH, Dischinger PC, Rixen D, Burgess AR, Addis MD, O'Quinn T, McCammon L, Schmidhauser CB, Marsh P, Hodge PA, Bents F. Airbag protection versus compartment intrusion effect determines the pattern of injuries in multiple trauma motor vehicle crashes. J Trauma. December 1996;41(6):935-951.
2004	McGwin G Jr, Metzger J, Rue LW III. The influence of side airbags on the risk of head and thoracic injury after motor vehicle collisions. J Trauma. March 2004;56(3):512-517.
2008	Thor CP. Characteristics of Thoracic Organ Injuries in Frontal Crashes [Master's thesis]. Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University; December 10, 2008.