Osteons are the end product of cortical bone remodeling. Changes in their mechanical properties may be an indicator of overall bone health. Aszenci and Bonucci first evaluated the compressive properties of individual osteons in 1968. However, these results have never been independently validated and technological advances allow for further investigation of osteon mechanics. In the present study, an experimental protocol was established such that osteons ~250 µm in diameter were successfully extracted from human cortical bone (males, ages 93 and 64) and loaded in compression. Both micro-computed tomography and second harmonic generation (SHG) microscopy imaging methods were incorporated into the protocol to improve the structural and compositional assessment of each osteon. Further, a high-resolution videography system was used to monitor the osteons during mechanical testing, permitting insight into deformation mechanisms in situ. The results show that the older donor osteons (male, age 93 (n = 13)) were stiffer (p = 0.04) and more highly mineralized (p = 0.03), while the younger donor osteons (male, 64 (n = 14)) exhibited more heterogeneity in the measured mechanical properties with the presence of both stiff and more compliant osteons. SHG intensity indicated predominantly longitudinal fiber alignment for all osteons while the videography data revealed three distinct failure modes and confirmed that whitening observed during yielding of macroscale bone specimens represents failure at the local level. The stiffness and strength of the younger donor osteons were heavily dependent on the gross structure of the osteon, while these properties were dominated by collagen orientation in the older donor osteons.