Roof strength and injury risk in rollover crashes

wbldb

Brumbelow, Matthew L.¹; Teoh, Eric R.¹; Zuby, David S.¹; McCartt, Anne T.¹

Roof strength and injury risk in rollover crashes

Traffic Inj Prev. 2009;10(3):252-265

©2009 Taylor & Francis Group, LLC

Affiliations

¹Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, Arlington, Virginia, USA
Abstract and keywords

Objective: Previous studies have reported that roof strength as measured in FMVSS 216 is unrelated to occupant injury risk in actual rollovers. However, those studies did not control for important confounding factors. The present study reevaluated roof strength and injury risk using a single class of vehicles with similar driver and vehicle usage characteristics in the expectation that some potential confounders will be controlled by this focused analysis. Alternative roof strength measures also were examined in case strength-to-weight ratio (SWR) at 5 inches, the measure in FMVSS 216, is not the best measure.

Methods: Eleven midsize SUV roof designs were crushed according to FMVSS 216 protocol. Force was measured continuously, and the maximum force and the amount of energy used to achieve crush of 2, 5, and 10 inches were recorded; these six measures of roof strength were evaluated both directly and after normalization for vehicle weight. After controlling for other potentially confounding variables, logistic regression models estimated the effect of each of the twelve roof strength measures on risk of fatal or incapacitating injuries to drivers in single-vehicle rollover crashes. Crash data were obtained from fourteen states.

Results: All roof strength measures correlated inversely, and similarly, with risk of fatal/incapacitating injury in single-vehicle rollovers. Across all states, 12 percent of drivers sustained fatal/incapacitating injuries, but individual state rates varied from 6 to 24 percent. Among available variables, only state substantially affected the estimated effect of roof strength; it was kept in the final models with roof strength, driver age, and static stability factor (SSF). Driver age was retained because it had a significant effect on injury outcome and SSF was retained for theoretical reasons. This model estimated that a one-unit increase in strength-to-weight ratio (SWR) within 5 inches of crush was associated with 24 percent lower risk of fatal/incapacitating injury (95% CI: 15–33). Ejection was lower by 41 percent (95% CI: 30–51), and injury risk among nonejected occupants was lower by 16 percent (95% CI: 3–29).

Conclusions: The FMVSS 216 measure of roof strength related strongly to occupant protection in real-world rollover crashes in this study, which restricted analysis to vehicles with reasonably homogeneous driver and usage characteristics and accounted for state variation in injury rates. Further research should determine whether these results generalize to other vehicle types with different drivers and rollover risk. Research should also focus on factors other than roof strength, because even large increases in roof strength would leave many rollover crash deaths unaffected.

Keywords: Roofs; Rollover accidents; Injury probability; FMVSS; Regulations
Links

DOI: 10.1080/15389580902781343

PubMed: 19452367

WoS: 000266204700007
History

Received: 2008-06-05

Accepted: 2009-01-25

Cited Works (12)

Year	Entry
2003	Li G, Braver ER, Chen L-H. Fragility versus excessive crash involvement as determinants of high death rates per vehicle-mile of travel among older drivers. Accid Anal Prev. 2003;35(2):227-235.
1989	Harwin EA, Emery L. The crash avoidance rollover study: a databasef or the investigation of single vehicle rollover crashes. In: Proceedings of the 12th International Technical Conference on Experimental Safety Vehicles (ESV). May 29–June 1, 1989; Göteborg, Sweden.470-477.
2001	Friedman D, Nash CE. Advanced roof design for rollover protection. In: Proceedings of the 17th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles (ESV). June 4-7, 2001; Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
1994	Digges KH, Malliaris AC, DeBlois HJ. Opportunities for casualty reduction in rollover crashes. In: Proceedings of the 14th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles (ESV). May 23-26, 1994; Munich, Germany.863-868.
2003	Moffatt EA, Cooper ER, Croteau JJ, Orlowski KF, Marth DR, Carter JW. Matched-pair rollover impacts of rollcaged and production roof cars using the controlled rollover impact system (CRIS). In: Proceedings of the SAE World Congress & Exhibition. March 3-6, 2003; Detroit, MI. Warrendale, PA: Society of Automotive Engineers. SAE 2003-01-0172.
1967	Haddon W Jr. The pre-crash, crash, and post-crash parts of the highway safety problem. In: 11th Annual Proceedings, Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine (AAAM). 1967; Philadelphia, PA.271-279.
2003	Digges KH, Eigen AM. Crash attributes that influence the severity of rollover crashes. In: Proceedings of the 18th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles (ESV). May 19-22, 2003; Nagoya, Japan.
1985	Orlowski KF, Bundorf RT, Moffatt EA. Rollover crash tests: the influence of roof strength on injury mechanics. In: Proceedings of the 29th Stapp Car Crash Conference. October 9-11, 1985; Washington, DC. Warrendale, PA: Society of Automotive Engineers:181-203. SAE 851734.
2003	Farmer CM. Reliability of police-reported information for determining crash and injury severity. Traffic Inj Prev. 2003;4(1):38-44.
1990	Bahling GS, Bundorf RT, Kaspzyk GS, Moffatt EA, Orlowski KF, Stocke JE. Rollover and drop tests: the influence of roof strength on injury mechanics using belted dummies. In: Proceedings of the 34th Stapp Car Crash Conference. November 4-7, 1990; Orlando, FL. Warrendale, PA: Society of Automotive Engineers:101-112. SAE 902314.
1995	Moffatt EA, Padmanaban J. The relationship between vehicle roof strength and occupant injury in rollover crash data. In: 39th Annual Proceedings, Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine (AAAM). October 16-18, 1995; Chicago, IL.245-267.
1989	Kahane CJ. An Evaluation of Door Locks and Roof Crush Resistance of Passenger Car: Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards 206 and 216. Washington, DC: National Highway Traffic Safety Administration; November 1989. NHTSA Technical Report DOT HS 807 489.

Cited By (14)

Year	Entry
2011	Ryb GE, Dischinger PC, McGwin G, Griffin RL. Crash-related mortality and model year: are newer vehicles safer? In: 55th Annual Proceedings, Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine (AAAM). October 3-5, 2011; Paris, France.113-121.
2012	Funk JR, Cormier JM, Bain CE, Wirth JL, Bonugli EB, Watson RA. Factors affecting ejection risk in rollover crashes. In: 56th Annual Proceedings, Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine (AAAM). October 14-17, 2012; Seattle, WA.203-211.
2009	Brumbelow ML, Teoh ER. Roof strength and injury risk in rollover crashes of passenger cars and SUVs. In: Proceedings of the 21st International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles (ESV). June 15-18, 2009; Stuttgart, Germany.
2011	Teoh ER, Lund AK. IIHS side crash test ratings and occupant death risk in real-world crashes. In: Proceedings of the 22nd International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles (ESV). June 13-16, 2011; Washington, DC.
2011	Bloch B. Protecting occupants in rollover crashes: case examples and latest technologies. In: Proceedings of the 22nd International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles (ESV). June 13-16, 2011; Washington, DC.
2013	Mattos GA, Grzebieta RH, Bambach MR, McIntosh AS. Passenger vehicle structural response in a dynamic rollover test. In: Proceedings of the 23rd International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles (ESV). May 27-30, 2013; Seoul, South Korea.
2013	Grzebieta R, Bambach M, McIntosh A, Mattos G, Simmons K, Rechnitzer G, Digges K. Replicating real world rollover crash injuries. In: Proceedings of the 23rd International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles (ESV). May 27-30, 2013; Seoul, South Korea.
2013	Grzebieta R, McIntosh A, Mattos G, Simmons K, Rechnitzer G, Mongiardini M, Dal Nevo R, Jackson C. Implementation of the UNSW Jordan rollover system at Sydney’s Crashlab test facility. In: Proceedings of the 23rd International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles (ESV). May 27-30, 2013; Seoul, South Korea.
2015	Zuby D. Consumer safety information programs at IIHS. In: Proceedings of the 24th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles (ESV). June 8-11, 2015; Gothenburg, Sweden.
2017	Brumbelow ML. Web traffic on IIHS.org vehicle rating pages. In: Proceedings of the 25th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles (ESV). June 5-8, 2017; Detroit, MI.
2019	Mattos G, Friedman K, Digges K, Nash C, Jordan A. Repeatability of the carousel dynamic stability and rollover test device. In: Proceedings of the 26th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles (ESV). June 10-13, 2019; Eindhoven, Netherlands.
2011	Teoh ER, Lund AK. IIHS side crash test ratings and occupant death risk in real-world crashes. Traffic Inj Prev. 2011;12(5):500-507.
2014	Tahan FJ. An Integrated Approach to Identify Thoracic Injuries in Rollover Crashes [PhD thesis]. Washington, DC: The George Washington University; January 31, 2014.
2013	Lockerby JW. Roof Deformation in Vehicle Rollover: The Case for Including an Energy Criterion in Vehicle Crashworthiness Evaluation [Master's thesis]. Charlottesville, VA: University of Virginia; December 2013.