Biomechanical impact testing of synthetic versus human cadaveric tibias for predicting injury risk during pedestrian-vehicle collisions

Cameron, Muir W.; Schemitsch, Emil H.; Zdero, Radovan; Quenneville, Cheryl E.

Affiliations

¹Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, Scotland

²Department of Surgery, Western University, London, ON, Canada

³Department of Mechanical and Materials Engineering, Western University, London, ON, Canada

⁴Department of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering, Ryerson University, Toronto, ON, Canada

⁵Department of Mechanical Engineering, McMaster University, Hamilton, ON, Canada

⁶School of Biomedical Engineering, McMaster University, Hamilton, ON, Canada

Abstract and keywords

Objective: The tibia is the most commonly fractured long bone in a pedestrian-vehicle collision. The standard injury assessment tool is the “legform,” a device that mimics the human lower limb under impact loads. These devices are designed to identify the impact load that will cause the onset of injury, rather than replicate the type and severity of fracture. Thus, this study is the first to determine if composite tibias made by Sawbones (Pacific Research Labs, Vashon, WA, USA) designed for orthopedic biomechanics research, could also potentially be used for traffic safety research by simulating both the damage tolerance of human cadaveric tibias for peak force and bending moment and the fracture patterns themselves, thereby more accurately predicting injury type during real-world pedestrian-vehicle collisions.

Methods: Synthetic tibias (n = 6) and human cadaveric tibias (n = 6) were impacted at midshaft at 8.3 m/s (i.e., 30 km/h) under 3-point bending using a pneumatic impacting apparatus. Fracture force, bending moment, and fracture patterns were compared between the two groups, and Weibull survivability curves generated for force and moment results, to identify injury risk thresholds.

Results: There was no difference for synthetic vs. cadaveric tibias regarding impact force (4271+/-938 N vs. 4889+/-993 N, p = 0.44) or bending moment at fracture (275+/-64 Nm vs. 302+/-107 Nm, p = 0.69). Force-time curves for all tibias were similar in shape based on the first three Principal Components (p > 0.14). Weibull survivability curves had differences in shape and in the 10% risk of fracture limits, with force thresholds of 2873 N for the synthetic vs. 3386 N for the cadaveric, and bending moment limits of 180 Nm for the synthetic compared to 157 Nm for the cadaveric. All fracture patterns were clinically realistic, but not consistent between groups. The coefficient of variation for synthetic tibias was >0.2 for both peak force and bending moment, which precludes their use as a reproducible test surrogate for injury prediction.

Conclusions: Synthetic composite tibias offer the potential for developing a frangible test surrogate, and matched cadaveric response in several respects. However, the repeatability was not high enough for them to be used in their present form for injury prediction.

Keywords: Biomechanics; synthetic; cadaver; tibia; pedestrianvehicle collisions; fracture

Links

DOI: 10.1080/15389588.2020.1714603

PubMed: 32023127

WoS: 000512915700001

History

Received: 2018-09-27

Accepted: 2020-01-07

Cited Works (9)

Year	Entry
2013	Rafaels KA, Gillich PJ, Ehlers RZ, Duvall PS. Lower leg injuries in dismounted military personnel from buried explosive. In: Proceedings of the 2013 International IRCOBI Conference on the Biomechanics of Injury. September 11-13, 2013; Gothenburg, Sweden.171-182.
2003	Konosu A, Tanahashi M. Development of a biofidelic flexible pedestrian legform impactor. Stapp Car Crash J. 2003;47:459-472. SAE 2003-22-0020.
1985	Nyquist GW, Cheng R, El-Bohy AAR, King AI. Tibia bending: strength and response. In: Proceedings of the 29th Stapp Car Crash Conference. October 9-11, 1985; Washington, DC. Warrendale, PA: Society of Automotive Engineers:99-112. SAE 851728.
2011	Quenneville CE, McLachlin SD, Greeley GS, Dunning CE. Injury tolerance criteria for short-duration axial impulse loading of the isolated tibia. J Trauma. January 2011;70(1):E13-E18.
2007	Zander O, Lorenz B, Gehring D-U, Leßmann P. Prediction of lower extremity injury risks during an impact on modern car fronts with a flexible pedestrian legform impactor and the pedestrian legform impactor according to EEVC WG 17. In: Proceedings of the 20th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles (ESV). June 18-21, 2007; Lyon, France.
2018	Martinez AA, Chakravarty AB, Quenneville CE. The effect of impact duration on the axial fracture tolerance of the isolated tibia during automotive and military impacts. J Mech Behav Biomed Mater. February 2018;78:315.
2015	Xu L, Bilkhu S, Farooq I, Hickman J, Jensen J, McCabe K, Nusholtz G. Performance comparison and repeatability evaluation of the Flex PLI and the TRL pedestrian legform impactors. In: Proceedings of the 24th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles (ESV). June 8-11, 2015; Gothenburg, Sweden.
2004	Kerrigan JR, Drinkwater DC, Kam CY, Murphy DB, Ivarsson BJ, Crandall JR, Patrie J. Tolerance of the human leg and thigh in dynamic latero-medial bending. Int J Crashworthiness. 2004;9(6):607-623.
2003	Kerrigan JR, Bhalla KS, Madeley NJ, Funk JR, Bose D, Crandall JR. Experiments for establishing pedestrian-impact lower limb injury criteria. In: Proceedings of the SAE World Congress & Exhibition. March 3-6, 2003; Detroit, MI. Warrendale, PA: Society of Automotive Engineers. SAE 2003-01-0895.

Cited By (1)

Year	Entry
2020	Steinmann N. Development of a Modified Anthropomorphic Test Device for the Quantification of Behind Shield Blunt Impacts [Master's thesis]. Hamilton, ON: McMaster University; August 2020.