An in-Vitro and Finite Element Investigation on the Efficacy of Unloader Knee Braces on Meniscus Strain and Tibiofemoral Pressure

The medial and lateral menisci, situated in the knee joint, are most injured soft tissues in the human body. Meniscus injuries can be isolated or occur concurrently with an anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury. Certain tears are not amenable to surgical intervention and non-invasive treatment options such as unloader knee braces are theorized to benefit the knee joint during a medial meniscus injury. Unloader braces have shown favourable outcomes for medial osteoarthritis; however, there is a knowledge gap regarding the efficacy of these braces as an intervention for the meniscus.

This study investigated the efficacy of two medial unloader braces (i.e., Rebound Cartilage and Unloader Fit) on the medial meniscus and tibiofemoral joint compartment during simulated activities of daily living (ADL) in healthy and injured ACL states. Posteromedial and anteromedial meniscus strains and tibiofemoral cartilage pressures were measured on cadaveric specimens (n=10) while replicating gait, double leg squats (DLS), and single leg squats (SLS) using a dynamic knee simulator. In a complementary study, the experimental boundary conditions were applied to a pre-existing 50th percentile male right leg finite element (FE) model and the three ADLs were simulated in both ACL states with a simulated 10 Nm valgus moment (VM) unloader brace effect. The computational approach investigated additional outcomes that could not be measured experimentally such as posterolateral meniscus strains. Descriptive statistics were calculated for experimental strain and pressure outcomes and an analysis of variance (ANOVA) was conducted. Descriptive statistics were calculated for FE strain and pressures, and a cross-correlation analysis (CORA) was performed to compare between the FE model and experiment.

Both unloader braces resulted in significant reductions in mean and peak posteromedial meniscus strains during the ACL-intact state and significant differences in peak anteromedial meniscal strain (p<.05). Neither brace resulted in a significant difference in either strain outcome with an ACL deficiency (p>.05). There were no significant differences in tibial cartilage pressures with the application of both braces during the ACL-intact state (p>.05). Both braces resulted in an intended valgus unload during DLS and gait, though not during SLS despite reductions in posteromedial meniscus strain during SLS. Strain and pressure outcomes revealed that the RC brace significantly outperformed the UF brace (p<.05), as intended by the manufacturer, moreover, this was more noticeable in the ACL-deficient state.

The FE simulations demonstrated strong kinematic validity (CORA=0.74–0.99) with the experiments and the simulated ADLs matched experimental behaviours with ACL-deficient and VM conditions. FE posteromedial meniscus strain outcomes were within the experimental corridors and strain and pressure outcomes were within 1–2 SD of the mean experimental outcomes. Posterolateral meniscus strains were 7-16% higher than posteromedial meniscus strains and helped demonstrate affirmative unloading mechanics when compared to the unbraced scenario. The VM approximated unloader brace mechanics as evidenced by strain and pressure increases in the lateral meniscus and cartilage, respectively, and demonstrated higher efficacy in the ACL-intact state over the -deficient state, similar to the experiment.

This study addressed a major literature gap in knee brace biomechanics by quantifying the efficacy of two commercially available unloader braces on the medial meniscus and demonstrated the viability of a FE approach to measure deep tissue strain. Future research can consider these braces for clinical research in patients with a healthy ACL and the FE model or framework can be used to investigate a variable brace moment BC, additional ADLs, or injury states such as meniscectomies/osteoarthritis.

Year	Entry
2002	Rupp JD, Reed MP, Van Ee CA, Kuppa S, Wang SC, Goulet JA, Schneider LW. The tolerance of the human hip to dynamic knee loading. Stapp Car Crash J. 2002;46:211-228. SAE 2002-22-0011.
2001	Beillas P, Begeman PC, Yang KH, King AI, Arnoux P-J, Kang H-S, Kayvantash K, Brunet C, Cavallero C, Prasad P. Lower limb: advanced FE model and new experimental data. Stapp Car Crash J. 2001;45:469-494. SAE 2001-22-0022.
2013	Untaroiu CD, Yue N, Shin J. A finite element model of the lower limb for simulating automotive impacts. Ann Biomed Eng. March 2013;41(3):513-526.
2011	Gayzik FS, Moreno DP, Geer CP, Wuertzer SD, Martin RS, Stitzel JD. Development of a full body CAD dataset for computational modeling: a multi-modality approach. Ann Biomed Eng. October 2011;39(10):2568-2583.
2009	Ivarsson BJ, Genovese D, Crandall JR, Bolton JR, Untaroiu CD, Bose D. The tolerance of the femoral shaft in combined axial compression and bending loading. Stapp Car Crash J. 2009;53:251-290. SAE 2009-22-0010.
1992	Spilker RL, Donzelli PS, Mow VC. A transversely isotropic biphasic finite element model of the meniscus. J Biomech. September 1992;25(9):1027-1045.
2004	Fleming BC, Beynnon BD. In vivo measurement of ligament/tendon strains and forces: a review. Ann Biomed Eng. 2004;32(3):318-328.
2002	Irwin AL, Mertz HJ, Elhagediab AM, Moss S. Guidelines for assessing the biofidelity of side impact dummies of various sizes and ages. Stapp Car Crash J. 2002;46:297-319. SAE 2002-22-0016.
1984	An KN, Takahashi K, Harrigan TP, Chao EY. Determination of muscle orientations and moment arms. J Biomech Eng. August 1984;106(3):280-282.
1986	Butler DL, Kay MD, Stouffer DC. Comparison of material properties in fascicle-bone units from human patellar tendon and knee ligaments. J Biomech. 1986;19(6):425-432.
1989	Haut RC. Contact pressures in the patellofemoral joint during impact loading on the human flexed knee. J Orthop Res. March 1989;7(2):272-280.
2009	Gehre C, Gades H, Wernicke P. Objective rating of signals using test and simulation responses. In: Proceedings of the 21st International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles (ESV). June 15-18, 2009; Stuttgart, Germany.
1980	Fukubayashi T, Kurosawa H. The contact area and pressure distribution pattern of the knee: a study of normal and osteoarthrotic knee joints. Acta Orthop Scand. December 1980;51(5):871-879.
2005	Untaroiu C, Darvish K, Crandall J, Deng B, Wang J-T. A finite element model of the lower limb for simulating pedestrian impacts. Stapp Car Crash J. 2005;49:157-181. SAE 2005-22-0008.
1977	Repo RU, Finlay JB. Survival of articular cartilage after controlled impact. J Bone Joint Surg. December 1977;59A(8):1068-1076.
2008	Untaroiu CD, Ivarsson J, Genovese DR, Bose D, Crandall JR. Biomechanical injury response of leg subjected to combined axial compressive and bending loading. Biomed Sci Instrum. 2008;44:141-146.
2004	Kerrigan JR, Drinkwater DC, Kam CY, Murphy DB, Ivarsson BJ, Crandall JR, Patrie J. Tolerance of the human leg and thigh in dynamic latero-medial bending. Int J Crashworthiness. 2004;9(6):607-623.
2006	Chandrashekar N, Mansouri H, Slauterbeck J, Hashemi J. Sex-based differences in the tensile properties of the human anterior cruciate ligament. J Biomech. 2006;39(16):2943-2950.
2013	Vavalle NA, Jelen BC, Moreno DP, Stitzel JD, Gayzik FS. An evaluation of objective rating methods for full-body finite element model comparison to PMHS tests. Traffic Inj Prev. November 22, 2013;14(suppl 1):S87-S94.
1976	Kennedy JC, Hawkins RJ, Willis RB, Danylchuck KD. Tension studies of human knee ligaments: yield point, ultimate failure, and disruption of the cruciate and tibial collateral ligaments. J Bone Joint Surg. April 1976;58A(3):350-355.
1995	Tissakht M, Ahmed AM. Tensile stress-strain characteristics of the human meniscal material. J Biomech. April 1995;28(4):411-422.
1994	Race A, Amis AA. The mechanical properties of the two bundles of the human posterior cruciate ligament. J Biomech. January 1994;27(1):13-24.
2002	LeRoux MA, Setton LA. Experimental and biphasic FEM determinations of the material properties and hydraulic permeability of the meniscus in tension. J Biomech Eng. June 2002;124(3):315-321.
2007	Lohmander LS, Englund PM, Dahl LL, Roos EM. The long-term consequence of anterior cruciate ligament and meniscus injuries: osteoarthritis. Am J Sports Med. October 2007;35(10):1756-1769.
1976	Hori RY, Mockros LF. Indentation tests of human articular cartilage. J Biomech. 1976;9(4):259-268.
2003	Haut Donahue TL, Hull ML, Rashid MM, Jacobs CR. How the stiffness of meniscal attachments and meniscal material properties affect tibio-femoral contact pressure computed using a validated finite element model of the human knee joint. J Biomech. January 2003;36(1):19-34.
1991	Woo SL-Y, Hollis JM, Adams DJ, Lyon RM, Takai S. Tensile properties of the human femur-anterior cruciate ligament-tibia complex: the effects of specimen age and orientation. Am J Sports Med. 1991;19(3):217-225.
1994	Daniel DM, Stone ML, Dobson BE, Fithian DC, Rossman DJ, Kaufman KR. Fate of the ACL-injured patient: a prospective outcome study. Am J Sports Med. September–October 1994;22(5):632-644.
1998	Wu JZ, Herzog W, Epstein M. Effects of inserting a pressensor film into articular joints on the actual contact mechanics. J Biomech Eng. October 1998;120(5):655-659.
2017	Tomescu SS. Knee Tissue Strains and Effectiveness of a Novel Functional ACL Knee Brace During Dynamic in-Vitro Loading [Master's thesis]. University of Toronto; 2017.
2014	Bakker R. The Effect of Sagittal Plane Mechanics on Anterior Cruciate Ligament Strain During Jump Landing [Master's thesis]. University of Waterloo; 2014.
2004	Funk JR, Rudd RW, Kerrigan JR, Crandall JR. The effect of tibial curvature and fibular loading on the tibia index. Traffic Inj Prev. June 2004;5(2):164-172.
2007	Marshall SW, Covassin T, Dick R, Nassar LG, Agel J. Descriptive epidemiology of collegiate women's gymnastics injuries: National Collegiate Athletic Association injury surveillance system, 1988-1989 through 2003-2004. J Athl Train. April–June 2007;42(2):234-240.
1995	Bendjaballah MZ, Shirazi-Adl A, Zukor DJ. Biomechanics of the human knee joint in compression: reconstruction, mesh generation and finite element analysis. Knee. June 1995;2(2):69-79.
1998	Beynnon BD, Fleming BC. Anterior cruciate ligament strain in-vivo: a review of previous work. J Biomech. June 1998;31(6):519-525.
1990	Delp SL, Loan JP, Hoy MG, Zajac FE, Topp EL, Rosen JM. An interactive graphics-based model of the lower extremity to study orthopaedic surgical procedures. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng. 1990;37(8):757-767.
2007	Prodromos CC, Han Y, Rogowski J, Joyce B, Shi K. A meta-analysis of the incidence of anterior cruciate ligament tears as a function of gender, sport, and a knee injury–reduction regimen. Arthroscopy. December 2007;23(12):1320-1325.
2003	Kerrigan JR, Bhalla KS, Madeley NJ, Funk JR, Bose D, Crandall JR. Experiments for establishing pedestrian-impact lower limb injury criteria. In: Proceedings of the SAE World Congress & Exhibition. March 3-6, 2003; Detroit, MI. Warrendale, PA: Society of Automotive Engineers. SAE 2003-01-0895.

Year

Entry

2002

Rupp JD, Reed MP, Van Ee CA, Kuppa S, Wang SC, Goulet JA, Schneider LW. The tolerance of the human hip to dynamic knee loading. Stapp Car Crash J. 2002;46:211-228. SAE 2002-22-0011.

2001

Beillas P, Begeman PC, Yang KH, King AI, Arnoux P-J, Kang H-S, Kayvantash K, Brunet C, Cavallero C, Prasad P. Lower limb: advanced FE model and new experimental data. Stapp Car Crash J. 2001;45:469-494. SAE 2001-22-0022.

2013

Untaroiu CD, Yue N, Shin J. A finite element model of the lower limb for simulating automotive impacts. Ann Biomed Eng. March 2013;41(3):513-526.

2011

Gayzik FS, Moreno DP, Geer CP, Wuertzer SD, Martin RS, Stitzel JD. Development of a full body CAD dataset for computational modeling: a multi-modality approach. Ann Biomed Eng. October 2011;39(10):2568-2583.

2009

Ivarsson BJ, Genovese D, Crandall JR, Bolton JR, Untaroiu CD, Bose D. The tolerance of the femoral shaft in combined axial compression and bending loading. Stapp Car Crash J. 2009;53:251-290. SAE 2009-22-0010.