Adult human meniscus fibrocartilage is avascular and nonhealing after injury. Meniscus tissue engineering aims to replace injured meniscus with lab-grown fibrocartilage. Dynamic culture systems may be necessary to generate fibrocartilage of sufficient mechanical properties for implantation;​ however, the optimal static preculture conditions before initiation of dynamic culture are unknown. This study thus investigated the time course of fibrocartilage formation by human meniscus fibrochondrocytes on a three-dimensional biomaterial scaffold under various static conditions. Human meniscus fibrochondrocytes from partial meniscectomy were expanded to passage 1 (P1) or P2 (3.0 ± 0.4 and 6.5 ± 0.6 population doublings), seeded onto type I collagen scaffolds, and grown in hypoxia (HYP, 3% O₂) or normoxia (NRX, 20% O₂) for 3, 6, and 9 weeks. Mechanical properties were not different between P1 and P2 cell-based constructs. Mechanical properties were lower in HYP, increased continually in NRX only, and were positively correlated with glycosaminoglycan content and accumulation of hyaline cartilage-like matrix components. The most mechanically competent tissues (NRX/9 weeks) reached 1/5 of the native meniscus instantaneous compression modulus but had an increasingly hypertrophic matrix-forming phenotype. HYP consistently suppressed the hypertrophic phenotype. The results provide baselines of engineered meniscus fibrocartilage properties under static conditions, which can be used to select a preculture strategy for dynamic culture depending on the desired combination of mechanical properties, hyaline cartilage-like matrix abundance, and hypertrophic phenotype.