Low back pain is a prevalent condition that affects the global population. The lumbar facet capsular ligament is a source of pain since the collagenous tissue of the ligament is innervated with sensory neurons that deform with the capsule’s stretch. Regional differences in the microstructural and macrostructural anatomy of the spinal facets affect its capsule’s mechanical behavior. Although there are many studies of the cervical facet in human and rodent models, the lumbar capsular ligament’s multiscale behavior is less well-defined. This study characterizes the macroscale and fiber-scale changes of the rat lumbar facet capsule during tensile failure loading. An integrated polarized light imaging setup captured local fiber alignment during 0.08 mm/s distraction of 7 lumbar facets. Force, displacement, strain, and circular variance were measured at several points along the failure curve:​ the first instance when the local collagen fiber network realigns differentially (anomalous realignment), yield, the first peak in force corresponding to the capsule’s first failure, and peak force, defined as ultimate rupture. Those outcomes were compared across events. While each of force, displacement, and average maximum principal strain increased with applied tension, so did the circular variance of the collagen, suggesting that the fibers were becoming more disorganized. From the fiber alignment maps collected at each mechanical event, the number of anomalous realignment events were counted and found to increase dramatically with loading. The increased collagen disorganization and increasing regions of such disorganization in the facet capsule during loading can provide insights about how loading to the ligament afferent nerves may be activated and thereby produce pain.