Comminuted proximal tibia fractures are an ongoing surgical challenge. This “proof of concept” study is the first step in designing a new percutaneous plate for this injury under toe-touch weight-bearing as prescribed after surgery. Finite element simulations generated design curves for overall stiffness, bone and implant stress, and interfragmentary motion using 3 fixations (no, 1, or 2 “kickstand” (KS) screws across the fracture gap) over a range of plate elastic moduli (E_P = 5 to 200 GPa). Combining well-established optimization criteria to enhance callus formation (i.e. 0.2 mm ≤ axial interfragmentary motion ≤ 1 mm;​ shear / axial interfragmentary motion ratio < 1.6), lessen stress shielding (i.e. bone stress under the proposed plate > bone stress under a traditional titanium or steel plate), and reduce steel screw breakage (i.e. screw max stress < ultimate tensile stress of steel) resulted in plate design recommendations:​ 172.6 ≤ E_P < 200 GPa (no KS screw), 79.8 ≤ EP < 100 GPa (1 KS screw), and 4.9 ≤ E_P < 100 GPa (2 KS screws). A prototype plate could be made from materials currently used or proposed for orthopaedics, such as polymers, fiber-reinforced polymers, fiber metal laminates, metal foams, or shape memory alloys.