Objective: The objectives of this study were to examine the axial response of the clavicle under quasistatic compressions replicating the body boundary conditions and to quantify the sensitivity of finite element-predicted fracture in the clavicle to several parameters.
Methods: Clavicles were harvested from 14 donors (age range 14-56 years). Quasistatic axial compression tests were performed using a custom rig designed to replicate in situ boundary conditions. Prior to testing, high-resolution computed tomography (CT) scans were taken of each clavicle. From those images, finite element models were constructed. Factors varied parametrically included the density used to threshold cortical bone in the CT scans, the presence of trabecular bone, the mesh density, Young's modulus, the maximum stress, and the element type (shell vs. solid, triangular vs. quadrilateral surface elements).
Results: The experiments revealed significant variability in the peak force (2.41 ± 0.72 kN) and displacement to peak force (4.9 ± 1.1 mm), with age (p < .05) and with some geometrical traits of the specimens. In the finite element models, the failure force and location were moderately dependent upon the Young's modulus. The fracture force was highly sensitive to the yield stress (80-110 MPa).
Conclusion: Neither fracture location nor force was strongly dependent on mesh density as long as the element size was less than 5 x 5 mm². Both the fracture location and force were strongly dependent upon the threshold density used to define the thickness of the cortical shell.
|2005||Iwamoto M, Miki K, Tanaka E. Ankle skeletal injury predictions using anisotropic inelastic constitutive model of cortical bone taking into account damage evolution. Stapp Car Crash J. 2005;49:133-156. SAE 2005-22-0007.|
|2000||Wirtz DC, Schiffers N, Pandorf T, Radermacher K, Weichert D, Forst R. Critical evaluation of known bone material properties to realize anisotropic fe-simulation of the proximal femur. J Biomech. October 2000;33(10):1325-1330.|
|2006||Ruan JS, El-Jawahri R, Rouhana SW, Barbat S, Prasad P. Analysis and evaluation of the biofidelity of the human body finite element model in lateral impact simulations according to ISO-TR9790 procedures. Stapp Car Crash J. 2006;50:491-507. SAE 2006-22-0018.|
|2005||Nalla RK, Stölken JS, Kinney JH, Ritchie RO. Fracture in human cortical bone: local fracture criteria and toughening mechanisms. J Biomech. July 2005;38(7):1517-1525.|
|1998||Keyak JH, Rossi SA, Jones KA, Skinner HB. Prediction of femoral fracture load using automated finite element modeling. J Biomech. May 12, 1998;31(2):125-133.|
|2000||Keyak J, Rossi S. Prediction of femoral fracture load using finite element models: an examination of stress- and strain-based failure theories. J Biomech. 2000;33(2):209-214.|
|1997||Camacho DLA, Hopper RH, Lin GM, Myers BS. An improved method for finite element mesh generation of geometrically complex structures with application to the skullbase. J Biomech. 1997;30(10):1067-1070.|
|2003||Ruan J, El-Jawahri R, Chai L, Barbat S, Prasad P. Prediction and analysis of human thoracic impact responses and injuries in cadaver impacts using a full human body finite element model. Stapp Car Crash J. 2003;47:299-321. SAE 2003-22-0014.|
|2005||Charpail E, Trosseille X, Petit P, Laporte S, Lavaste F, Vallancien G. Characterization of PMHS ribs: a new test methodology. Stapp Car Crash J. 2005;49:183-198. SAE 2005-22-0009.|
|2006||Charpail E. Analyse du comportement mecanique des cotes humaines en dynamique [Mechanical Behavior Analysis of Human Ribs in Dynamics] [PhD thesis]. Paris, France: l’École Nationale Supérieure d'Arts et Métiers; October 27, 2006.|
|2005||Kimpara H, Lee JB, Yang KH, King AI, Iwamoto M, Watanabe I, Miki K. Development of a three-dimensional finite element chest model for the 5th percentile female. Stapp Car Crash J. 2005;49:251-269. SAE 2005-22-0012.|
|1991||Lotz JC, Cheal EJ, Hayes WC. Fracture prediction for the proximal femur using finite element models, I: linear analysis. J Biomech Eng. 1991;113(4):353-360.|
|1998||Ladd AJC, Kinney JH. Numerical errors and uncertainties in finite-element modeling of trabecular bone. J Biomech. October 1998;31(10):941-945.|
|2008||Duprey S, Bruyere K, Verriest J-P. Influence of geometrical personalization on the simulation of clavicle fractures. J Biomech. 2008;41(1):200-207.|
|1996||Ford CM, Keaveny TM, Hayes WC. The effect of impact direction on the structural capacity of the proximal femur during falls. J Bone Miner Res. March 1996;11(3):377-383.|
|2004||Compigne S, Caire Y, Quesnel T, Verries J-P. Non-injurious and injurious impact response of the human shoulder three-dimensional analysis of kinematics and determination of injury threshold. Stapp Car Crash J. 2004;48:89-123. SAE 2004-22-0005.|
|1991||Lotz JC, Cheal EJ, Hayes WC. Fracture prediction for the proximal femur using finite element models, II: nonlinear analysis. J Biomech Eng. 1991;113(4):361-364.|
|2005||Kemper AR, McNally C, Kennedy EA, Manoogian SJ, Rath AL, Ng TP, Stitzel JD, Smith EP, Duma SM, Matsuoka F. Material properties of human rib cortical bone from dynamic tension coupon testing. Stapp Car Crash J. 2005;49:199-230. SAE 2005-22-0010.|
|2013||Zhang Q, Kerrigan J, Kindig M, Arregui-Dalmases C, Duprey S, Crandall J. Axial injury tolerance of the clavicle and the effect of age, gender and boundary conditions. In: Proceedings of the 9th Ohio State University Injury Biomechanics Symposium. May 19-21, 2013; Columbus, OH.|
|2013||Li Z, Kindig MW, Kerrigan JR, Kent RW, Crandall JR. Development and validation of a subject-specific finite element model of a human clavicle. Comput Methods Biomech Biomed Eng. 2013;16(8):819-829.|
|2015||Perz R, Toczyski J, Subit D. Variation in the human ribs geometrical properties and mechanical response based on X-ray computed tomography images resolution. J Mech Behav Biomed Mater. January 2015;41:292-301.|
|2010||Li Z, Kindig MW, Subit D, Kent RW. Influence of mesh density, cortical thickness and material properties on human rib fracture prediction. Med Eng Phys. November 2010;32(9):998-1008.|