Three-dimensional local measurements of bone strain and displacement:​ comparison of three digital volume correlation approaches

Palanca, Marco; Tozzi, Gianluca; Cristofolini, Luca; Viceconti, Marco; Dall'Ara, Enrico

Affiliations

¹School of Engineering and Architecture, University of Bologna, Via Terracini 28, Bologna 40131, Italy

²School of Engineering, University of Portsmouth, Anglesea Building, Anglesea Road, Portsmouth PO1 3DJ, UK

³School of Engineering and Architecture, University of Bologna, Viale Risorgimento 2, Bologna 40136, Italy

⁴Department of Mechanical Engineering and INSIGNEO Institute for In Silico Medicine, University of Sheffield, Sir Frederick Mappin Building, Pam Liversidge Building, Sheffield S1 3JD, UK

Abstract and keywords

Different digital volume correlation (DVC) approaches are currently available or under development for bone tissue micromechanics. The aim of this study was to compare accuracy and precision errors of three DVC approaches for a particular three-dimensional (3D) zero-strain condition. Trabecular and cortical bone specimens were repeatedly scanned with a micro-computed tomography (CT). The errors affecting computed displacements and strains were extracted for a known virtual translation, as well as for repeated scans. Three DVC strategies were tested: two local approaches, based on fast-Fourier-transform (DaVis-FFT) or direct-correlation (DaVis-DC), and a global approach based on elastic registration and a finite element (FE) solver (ShIRT-FE). Different computation subvolume sizes were tested. Much larger errors were found for the repeated scans than for the virtual translation test. For each algorithm, errors decreased asymptotically for larger subvolume sizes in the range explored. Considering this particular set of images, ShIRT-FE showed an overall better accuracy and precision (a few hundreds microstrain for a subvolume of 50 voxels). When the largest subvolume (50–52 voxels) was applied to cortical bone, the accuracy error obtained for repeated scans with ShIRT-FE was approximately half of that for the best local approach (DaVis-DC). The difference was lower (250 microstrain) in the case of trabecular bone. In terms of precision, the errors shown by DaVis-DC were closer to the ones computed by ShIRT-FE (differences of 131 microstrain and 157 microstrain for cortical and trabecular bone, respectively). The multipass computation available for DaVis software improved the accuracy and precision only for the DaVis-FFT in the virtual translation, particularly for trabecular bone. The better accuracy and precision of ShIRT-FE, followed by DaVis-DC, were obtained with a higher computational cost when compared to DaVis-FFT. The results underline the importance of performing a quantitative comparison of DVC methods on the same set of samples by using also repeated scans, other than virtual translation tests only. ShIRT-FE provides the most accurate and precise results for this set of images. However, both DaVis approaches show reasonable results for large nodal spacing, particularly for trabecular bone. Finally, this study highlights the importance of using sufficiently large subvolumes, in order to achieve better accuracy and precision.

Keywords: digital volume correlation; registration; micro-CT; zero-strain test; bone; accuracy; precision

Links

DOI: 10.1115/1.4030174

PubMed: 25807338

WoS: 000356073400007

History

Received: 2014-12-08

Revised: 2015-03-13

Online: 2015-06-02

Cited Works (11)

Year	Entry
2001	Nicolella DP, Nicholls AE, Lankford J, Davy DT. Machine vision photogrammetry: a technique for measurement of microstructural strain in cortical bone. J Biomech. January 2001;34(1):135-139.
2013	Madi K, Tozzi G, Zhang Q, Tong J, Cossey A, Au A, Hollis D, Hild F. Computation of full-field displacements in a scaffold implant using digital volume correlation and finite element analysis. Med Eng Phys. September 2013;35(9):1298.
2002	Smith TS, Bay BK, Rashid MM. Digital volume correlation including rotational degrees of freedom during minimization. Exp Mech. September 2002;42(3):272-278.
2014	Dall’Ara E, Barber D, Viceconti M. About the inevitable compromise between spatial resolution and accuracy of strain measurement for bone tissue: a 3D zero-strain study. J Biomech. September 22, 2014;47(12):2956-2963.
2014	Gillard F, Boardman R, Mavrogordato M, Hollis D, Sinclair I, Pierron F, Browne M. The application of digital volume correlation (DVC) to study the microstructural behaviour of trabecular bone during compression. J Mech Behav Biomed Mater. January 2014;29:480-499.
2004	Bayraktar HH, Morgan EF, Niebur GL, Morris GE, Wong EK, Keaveny TM. Comparison of the elastic and yield properties of human femoral trabecular and cortical bone tissue. J Biomech. January 2004;37(1):27-35.
2014	Roberts BC, Perilli E, Reynolds KJ. Application of the digital volume correlation technique for the measurement of displacement and strain fields in bone: a literature review. J Biomech. March 21, 2014;47(5):923-934.
2012	Christen D, Levchuk A, Schori S, Schneider P, Boyd SK, Müller R. Deformable image registration and 3D strain mapping for the quantitative assessment of cortical bone microdamage. J Mech Behav Biomed Mater. April 2012;8:184-193.
2007	Liu L, Morgan EF. Accuracy and precision of digital volume correlation in quantifying displacements and strains in trabecular bone. J Biomech. 2007;40(15):3516-3520.
2012	Hussein AI, Barbone PE, Morgan EF. Digital volume correlation for study of the mechanics of whole bones. Procedia Eng. 2012;4:116-125.
1999	Bay BK, Smith TS, Fyhrie DP, Saad M. Digital volume correlation: three-dimensional strain mapping using X-ray tomography. Exp Mech. September 1999;39(3):217-226.

Cited By (29)

Year	Entry
2021	Peña Fernández M, Kao AP, Bonithon R, Howells D, link="bodey-andrew-j"Bodey AJ, Wanelik K, Witte F, Johnston R, Arora H, Tozzi G. Time-resolved in situ synchrotron-microct: 4D deformation of bone and bone analogues using digital volume correlation. Acta Biomater. September 1, 2021;131:424.
2020	Le Cann S, Tudisco E, Tägil M, Hall SA, Isaksson H. Bone damage evolution around integrated metal screws using x-ray tomography: in situ pullout and digital volume correlation. Front Bioeng Biotechnol. August 5, 2020;8:934.
2017	Dall’Ara E, Peña-Fernández M, Palanca M, Giorgi M, Cristofolini L, Tozzi G. Precision of digital volume correlation approaches for strain analysis in bone imaged with micro-computed tomography at different dimensional levels. Front Mater. November 8, 2017;4:31.
2016	Palanca M, Tozzi G, Cristofolini L. The use of digital image correlation in the biomechanical area: a review. Int Biomech. 2016;3(1):1-21.
2016	Palanca M, Cristofolini L, Dall’Ara E, Curto M, Innocente F, Danesi V, Tozzi G. Digital volume correlation can be used to estimate local strains in natural and augmented vertebrae: an organ-level study. J Biomech. December 8, 2016;49(16):3882-3890.
2017	Palanca M, Bodey AJ, Giorgi M, Viceconti M, Lacroix D, Cristofolini L, Dall'Ara E. Local displacement and strain uncertainties in different bone types by digital volume correlation of synchrotron microtomograms. J Biomech. June 14, 2017;58:27-36.
2019	Comini F, Palanca M, Cristofolini L, Dall’Ara E. Uncertainties of synchrotron microCT-based digital volume correlation bone strain measurements under simulated deformation. J Biomech. March 27, 2019;86:232-237.
2015	Grassi L, Isaksson H. Extracting accurate strain measurements in bone mechanics: a critical review of current methods. J Mech Behav Biomed Mater. October 2015;50:43-54.
2017	Chen Y, Dall’Ara E, Sales E, Manda K, Wallace R, Pankaj P, Viceconti M. Micro-CT based finite element models of cancellous bone predict accurately displacement once the boundary condition is well replicated: a validation study. J Mech Behav Biomed Mater. January 2017;65:644-651.
2017	Tozzi G, Dall’Ara E, Palanca M, Curto M, Innocente F, Cristofolini L. Strain uncertainties from two digital volume correlation approaches in prophylactically augmented vertebrae: local analysis on bone and cement-bone microstructures. J Mech Behav Biomed Mater. March 2017;67:117-126.
2018	Oliviero S, Giorgi M, Dall'Ara E. Validation of finite element models of the mouse tibia using digital volume correlation. J Mech Behav Biomed Mater. October 2018;86:172-184.
2020	Bokam P, Germaneau A, Rigoard P, Vendeuvre T, Valle V. Evaluation of fracture properties of cancellous bone tissues using digital image correlation/wedge splitting test method. J Mech Behav Biomed Mater. February 2020;102:103469.
2022	Knowles NK, Kusins J, Columbus MP, Athwal GS, Ferreira LM. Experimental DVC validation of heterogeneous micro finite element models applied to subchondral trabecular bone of the humeral head. J Orthop Res. September 2022;40(9):2039-2047.
2022	Kusins J, Knowles N, Martensson N, Columbus MP, Athwal GS, Ferreira LM. Full-field experimental analysis of the influence of microstructural parameters on the mechanical properties of humeral head trabecular bone. J Orthop Res. September 2022;40(9):2048-2056.
2020	Ryan MK, Oliviero S, Costa MC, Wilkinson JM, Dall’Ara E. Heterogeneous strain distribution in the subchondral bone of human osteoarthritic femoral heads, measured with digital volume correlation. Materials. 2020;13(20):4619.
2020	Turunen MJ, Le Cann S, Tudisco E, Lovric G, Patera A, Hall SA, Isaksson H. Sub-trabecular strain evolution in human trabecular bone. Sci Rep. 2020;10:13788.
2021	Loaiza J. Digital Volume Correlation as a Method for Estimating Load-Induced Deformations in the Human Spine [PhD thesis]. Boston University; 2021.
2016	Florencio FL. Multiscale Modelling of Trabecular Bone: From Micro to Macroscale [PhD thesis]. Edinburgh, Scotland: University of Edinburgh; 2016.
2018	Muckatira SK. Error Estimation in Whole Bone Microstrain Measurement When Using Digital Volume Correlation [Master's thesis]. University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign; 2018.
2020	Song H. The Effect of Mechanical Loading on Bone During Growth [PhD thesis]. University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign; 2020.
2016	Grassi L. Femoral Strength Prediction Using Finite Element Models: Validation of Models Based on CT and Reconstructed DXA Images Against Full-Field Strain Measurements [PhD thesis]. Lund, Sweden: Lund University; 2016.
2018	Peña Fernández M. X-Ray Biomechanical Imaging and Digital Volume Correlation of Bone: From Regeneration to Structure [PhD thesis]. Portsmouth, England: University of Portsmouth; December 2018.
2020	Karali A. Multi-Scale Evaluation of Bone Combining Indentation, in Situ XCT Mechanics and Digital Volume Correlation [PhD thesis]. Portsmouth, England: University of Portsmouth; 2020.
2016	Chen Y. Verification and Validation of MicroCT-Based Finite Element Models of Bone Tissue Biomechanics [PhD thesis]. Sheffield, UK: University of Sheffield; July 2016.
2018	Costa MC. Prediction of the Risk of Vertebral Fracture in Patients With Metastatic Bone Lesions as a Tool for More Effective Patients’ Management [PhD thesis]. University of Sheffield; November 2018.
2019	Oliviero S. Non-Invasive Prediction of Bone Mechanical Properties of the Mouse Tibia in Longitudinal Preclinical Studies [PhD thesis]. University of Sheffield; January 2019.
2017	Palanca M. In Vitro Full-Field Methods for the Biomechanical Characterization of Spine Segments [PhD thesis]. University of Bologna; March 2017.
2020	Zaluski D. Validation of Subject Specific Computed Tomography-Based Finite Element Models of the Human Proximal Tibia Using Full-Field Experimental Displacement Measurements from Digital Volume Correlation [Master's thesis]. University of Saskatchewan; December 2020.
2021	Kusins J. A Multi-Level Mechanical Assessment of the Shoulder Coupled With Evaluation of Upper Extremity Predictive Finite Element Models [PhD thesis]. University of Western Ontario; 2021.