Penetrating eye injuries are surgical emergencies with guarded visual prognosis. The purpose of the current study was to determine the force required to rupture the cornea with a penetrating object, and to study how this force is affected by the object geometry. Thirty-six human cadaveric eyes from donors of various ages were characterized for diameter, axial length, and pre-test intraocular pressure. In order to investigate the effects of specimen storage time on the tissue response, half of the specimens were tested within two weeks of donor expiration, and half of the specimens were stored at ­­­−4 °C for 12–18 months. Indenters of three different diameters (1.0, 1.5, and 2.0 mm) were lowered into the apex of the cornea until rupture. Resistance to displacement (stiffness), displacement at failure, and the force at failure were determined. Multi-variable regression analysis was used to determine associations of the input variables (indenter size, test speed, and tissue postmortem time) on the mechanics of the tissue response. Twenty-nine of the 36 specimens failed at the indenter location in the cornea, four failed at the limbus, and three failed in the sclera near sites of muscle attachment. The average force at failure caused by the 1.0 mm, 1.5 mm, and 2.0 mm indenters increased from 30.5 ± 5.5 N to 40.5 ± 8.3 N to 58.2 ± 14.5 N, respectively (p < 0.002). The force at failure was associated with the donor age (p < 0.001), and globe diameter (p < 0.041), but was not associated with pre-test intraocular pressure, tissue postmortem time, axial length, or speed of the indenter. This study has quantified the force-displacement and failure response of a large series of human cadaveric eyes subjected to penetrating indentation loads on the cornea. The results provide useful data for characterizing the relationship between corneal rupture and the geometry of a penetrating object.